Machines for logging = capital
labor = capital
software = capital.
A VCs business model is that of investing and profit. It's not altruistic, its a business. As such it is interested in profit. There are other methods to raise capital for a business but a VC may be a better option.
There is a case to be made about "negative externalities"[1] but talking about the whole of finance as unnecessary is throwing out the baby with the bath water.
[1] costs that aren't borne by the producer
The theory is that people spend money on what they desire, and so companies that generate more money satisfy more human values.
You will always find outliers and exceptions (caused by negative externalities usually), but this is true in general.
Distributed sharing economies, like that of most tribal organizations.
Look at any hunter gatherer tribe.
The key word here is "distributed". Distributed tribes are light weight and mobile by design. So they are rarely ever grouped into concentrations of 100,000+ members except for the occasional festival-like gatherings.
The use of the word "capital" here indicates a misunderstanding of the social dynamics of tribal economies.
They produce and consume that which they need together because of shared benefit.
Large scale centralized constructions like the Golden Gate Bridge, the Hoover Dam, or power grids are built to serve the stationary needs of the big city not the small, distributed, mobile tribe.
Indeed, every technological advancement has piggy backed on those before it.
Plenty of such tribes exist and have existed without centralized industrial infrastructure.
that's a pretty strong viewpoint to take. have you looked at 'the ascent of money' by niall-ferguson to get a more historical perspective on how we got here ?
So how does one expand a profitable business? Save up those earnings until you can buy a factory outright? Good luck with that. Meanwhile, I'll be financing the cost and leaving you in the dust.
But how often does such a use case actually come up in the real world (in the tech industry particularly)? Not saying it doesn't happen from time to time but it doesn't seem like the standard case these days.
It seems like a lot of time, VCs are just throwing money at specific companies in order to 'outfund' competitors who are also receiving money from a different set of VCs (they're all trying to run each other into the ground by artificially lowering profit margins).
Eventually, everyone realizes that the funding ultimately did nothing to neutralize the competition; most of the competitors are still alive and kicking (and new ones have since spawned up) - And the market is simply not big enough to meet everyone's projections/expectations.
Even startups which are doing well and generate profit tend to go on to raise money from VCs - This sounds ridiculous; they don't need the VC money but they raise money from the VC anyway because: 1. They need the connections and 2. They need the tech 'media' to promote them with a headline like "W raises $X millions from Y to disrupt/democratize Z!".
This highlights the fact that VCs have an oligolopy when it comes to economic connections and the media and they leverage it for their own needs.
Also the fact that crowdfunding was essentially illegal for so long is also scandalous - Not only do they hoard all important social connections and the media but they also have a stranglehold on politics.