Also, I'm concerned that I would not be able to discern any degradation in mental capacities due to my degraded mental capacities.
(Confession: I tried polyphasic sleep once, but didn't make it past the third day.)
To the health point: I think polyphasic sleep may also increase your desire for high fat, sugar and salt foods because it destroys the meal cycle.
Already, a few months ago, I tried to schedule myself into small healthy snacks every couple hours, instead of a few large and pretty unhealthy meals.
With this strict schedule on sleep, I'm eating within the first hour of waking up. (Eating a couple apples seem to help for the late night snacks.) Small breakfast after the 6am nap, small dinner right after my 6pm nap, etc. Some healthy-ish snacks sprinkled it the middle (but no too close to naptime).
But I wonder what the long-term health implications are, and how this fits in with relationships etc.
Also, I worked with a guy who did Uberman polyphasic sleep and he seemed out of it a lot, like he wasn't firing on all cylinders, at work.