There's no positive statement, there's a not in there. I do believe this makes a difference.
Re:What If Addiction Is Not a Disease?
by force_reboot on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @09:48PM
(#12258993)
when I say "positive statement" I mean in the positive/normative sense.
In fact its very common in this kind of discussion to see an argument like "If you believe <positive statement> then you must support <morally abhorrent policy>". But mostly the morally abhorrent policy doesn't actually follow from the positive statement, and if the person making this argument were forced to accept the positive statement, they would not in fact support the policy. In this debate