You do realize that I don't care who else argues something in a particular way in another domain, as long as an argument is correct in another domain!
>The problem is that to show something completely wrong (a year or two ago, you'd probably have linked to Picketty?) is a good way to make a career.
Not really. To piss on your own field, is a good way to be considered a pariah, a conspiracy theorist, a nut job etc. Not many grants coming to the self-doubting economist, and policy advisor positions either.
>But to dismiss a field of research, you really need better support.
Like self-deprecating citations from practitioners in the field?
(Even if expecting that is illogical to begin with -- since economics is what puts food on their table --, you'd be surprised how many economists have written self-deprecating critiques about economics)
You can say the same for any research area.
>> Like self-deprecating citations from practitioners in the field?
You know yourself that you can find that for most fields. I know I've heard it for biochemistry (regarding over relying on computer modelling for evaluating molecules, a long time ago; I have no idea what people to do now).
It is normal and necessary introspection about what you are doing -- "Do we do the right things? Are we going in a good direction?"
You do realize that is how the creationists argue about the biology academics? :-(
The problem is that to show something completely wrong (a year or two ago, you'd probably have linked to Picketty?) is a good way to make a career.
If you want to make a better argument for your position, go to post modernists or some other of the political sciences which generally have disappeared ten years later.
You could make a point, which I'd agree with, that your position is stronger than a conspiracy theory, there are too many precedents. But to dismiss a field of research, you really need better support.
>> should we actually evaluate arguments, or only think pre-made thoughts coming to us by way of citations?
Far outside our areas, that is a good heuristic...
About your references:
* Stephen A. Marglin seems to argue that the small society might be better. It is an interesting and important point. E.g. communism works OK in a village, but not for larger areas. Afaik, he don't present an alternative? (No one thinks the present democracy or capitalism is perfect, we just haven't found anything better.)
* "The Puzzle of Modern Economics: Science or Ideology?" got good reviews, but only by five readers. This seems to be a good overview:
"Is [economy] a.) dangerous mathematical formalism, b.) free market ideology, or c.) a vital guide to practical action? The correct answer, he concludes, is d.) all of the above"
Well, that isn't exactly controversial, is it? :-)
* Dani Rodrik seems to argue about when economy is a useful tool? It don't support that zero scientific content claim, either.