News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by merpnderp on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:30AM (#12248031)
Government granted monopolies lead to crappy service and you blame the free market?

When you get really rural where the main internet option is provided by microwave, you start seeing prices drop and bandwidth limits go up. I have a friend with faster speeds and no cap on microwave, while I'm stuck with a single choice by the government granted cable monopoly who's free to gouge me all they want.

But that's the difference between a free market and a heavily regulated one.

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by Hyperborian on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:15AM (#12247917)
So, you want to punish them all because most of them happen to not agree with your personal political views... even the minority that do agree with you, just for having the gall to live similarly to the ones who don't.

You seem like a nice person.

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by tbihl on Monday August 08, 2016 @12:22PM (#12248918)
Despite the generally stand-offish way parent made his point, there is some validity to wondering why we should provide broadband at such great distances.

I think these conversations tend to get dragged into "think of the farmers" because their work necessitates that they be spread out; accordingly we think of the beneficiaries of these programs as not needing to be held responsible for the hardships of living far away. The problem is, most people living so far apart are there by choice, because they see cheap space to build a big house and have a big yard. They're seeing low prices because we so often supply them with sewage lines, water pipes, paved roads, and other infrastructure, at costs which vastly exceed the receipts from their property taxes.

The people paying for these expensive infrastructure projects are the ones who live in places that pay for themselves, and then some. In many parts of the US, that's the poor people. They can't afford to own big houses outside of town, so instead they get stuck subsidizing those people.

This is particularly painful in transportation, where we take money away from cities who need that money to fund decent transit. Then we send it out to suburban areas to be spent by town leaders who just see easy money for building roads, rather than seeing that putting a 45mph, 5-lane road through downtown is suicide for the finances and vitality of a town.

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by ghaff on Monday August 08, 2016 @12:52PM (#12249133)
I suspect you're right that a lot of the people complaining the loudest about lack of rural broadband are people who have bought a 50 acre place out in the country because they want the space and the quiet. To be fair, they probably pay for a lot of infrastructure like septic but I agree with your basic point.

It's also true that there are some advantages to (near) universal service for many types of utilities, as we did historically with electricity and POTS. That said given existing alternatives to broadband fiber like satellite, I'm not convinced there's a pressing need to provide universal broadband even where it doesn't make financial sense.

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by snerbles on Monday August 08, 2016 @01:55PM (#12249608)
On plots that large, water is usually provided by a well and a local septic tank with leach field handles the sewage - these are typically factored into the cost of constructing a new dwelling.

Bear in mind that many of these residences were built before consumer access to the internet was widespread. You're better off with a terrestrial wireless, as satellite internet has severe latency and bandwidth limitations. Fortunately many rural households in the U.S. otherwise out of economic range of fiber are within rage of local WISPs, line-of-sight allowing.

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by wnevets on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:18AM (#12247940)
how is giving them what they want a punishment?
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by tanderson92 on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:07AM (#12247848)
Good policy isn't made by rewarding only those who voted for you and by making that your overriding concern.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by allengeorge on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:13AM (#12247897)
While I agree with you, I can understand the OP's sense of frustration: it's annoying to have people rail against taxes, the government, and laud the free market, and simultaneously defend government subsidies for industries they're working in and demand public infrastructure because the free market doesn't magically provide.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by protomyth on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:42AM (#12248138)
When has broadband been a free market? Its a monopoly situation for fibre. In the areas where small companies can get in we have pretty fast broadband[1], but regulations limit their service area. Established providers are able to lock out expanding companies with little effort. We don't need the subsidies. We need the regulators to get off their butts and let in the competition.

1) BEK does 200M fibre connections with no data cap in rural North Dakota. Plenty of these companies exist and are profitable.

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by snuxoll on Monday August 08, 2016 @11:38AM (#12248590)
It's a little unfair to group all rural populations up as a bunch of conservatives who want to complain about taxes but reap benefits of subsidies, however. The little farming community my grandfather has lived in his whole life is a fairly blue district surrounded by the sea of red that is northern Idaho - there's still some "keep the gubmit out of my life" people up there, but everyone I talk to up there was a bunch of pro-Sanders liberals who wanted better lives for their children and grandchildren.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by refurb on Monday August 08, 2016 @12:22PM (#12248914)
who wanted better lives for their children and grandchildren

As opposed to the Republicans who want a worse life for their children and grandchildren?

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by snuxoll on Monday August 08, 2016 @01:10PM (#12249276)
I'm not going to generalize the entire republican voter base, but they contain a disproportionate number of "I've got mine, sod off" types of people backing them (not that the current democratic party could be seen as much better). Point is though, not every person who lives in a rural area is some idiot that complains about paying taxes while raking in farming subsidies paid by said taxes.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by refurb on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:40PM (#12252218)
This is why American politics is so poisonous. When people disagree with you, it's not because they have a different point of view, it's because they're "bad".
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:51PM (#12252268)
On that note, I found this talk on Moral Politics by George Lakoff[1] elsewhere on HN.

The basic idea is that people who have different political opinions to you aren't necessarily stupid or greedy or bad actors, they just have different morals and therefore a different set of rationales.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5f9R9MtkpqM

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by refurb on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @01:30AM (#12252802)
Honestly, I would estimate 95% of Americans all have the same goals for the country. A healthy environment, prosperous economy, healthy population, stability, etc.

The differences come about as to how to get there. If you have different foundational beliefs as to how things work, of course you'll disagree as to what needs to be done to fix things.

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:49PM (#12252255)
they contain a disproportionate number of "I've got mine, sod off" types of people backing them (not that the current democratic party could be seen as much better).

First you say you're not going to generalise, then you do. Then you negate your next point by saying that democrat voters are just as bad. What are you trying to say?

To your last point, people who complain about paying taxes while being the beneficiaries of government largess aren't idiots. I'd posit they're probably smarter than I am, at least financially because I only ever pay tax.

[dead]
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by logfromblammo on Monday August 08, 2016 @02:09PM (#12249717)
Whereas in contrast, Democrats will offer every comfort to your children, and make your grandchildren pay for it.

It is unclear to me as to why I should prefer one over the other, when the option to build the best and most durable infrastructure we can afford without indebting future generations beyond the benefit they will realize from it has not yet been explored.

Both of the major political parties in the US are actively hostile to both sound economic policy and universally beneficial infrastructure development. They have been captured by the private interests of the business-owning class (which includes to some extent the middle-class stockholders).

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by mason240 on Monday August 08, 2016 @01:28PM (#12249399)
It's almost like they have a nuanced view on the role of government where it is involved with building infrastructure and not being heavy handed with regulation and not spending large amounts on welfare programs.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by nitwit005 on Monday August 08, 2016 @01:55PM (#12249602)
Or they have self-contradictory political views, or they're dishonest about what they really believe, or they say different things when it's in their self interest.

Or, quite likely, a mix of all of the above.

Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by wnevets on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:10AM (#12247875)
If they don't want your reward is it really good policy?
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by tanderson92 on Monday August 08, 2016 @03:14PM (#12250178)
not voting for you =/= not supporting your new policy, Similarly, a vote for a candidate does not necessarily reflect agreement with the entire platform.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by realusername on Monday August 08, 2016 @10:14AM (#12247909)
If people had the same reasoning before, you would have no telephone, no roads, no trains and no postal system.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by nitwit005 on Monday August 08, 2016 @02:02PM (#12249657)
When the postal system started, localities had to prove the roads were good enough for postal delivery. Most of those rural roads were maintained by the locals.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by _archon_ on Monday August 08, 2016 @04:20PM (#12250596)
Now, they're maintained by taxpayers, i.e. the locals. What's your point?
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by nitwit005 on Monday August 08, 2016 @05:09PM (#12250891)
It was unsubsidized and somewhat free market oriented? Not completely obviously, but people literally building their own roads, and then paying for mail delivery is definitely leaning that way.
Re:How to Give Rural America Broadband? Look to the Early 1900s by clarkmoody on Monday August 08, 2016 @12:34PM (#12248991)
And if the Civil Aviation Board didn't exist there'd be no way to fly safely between cities within the ... wait.