News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surfer’s ‘everything theory’ wipes out by yummyfajitas on Sunday March 28, 2010 @09:54AM (#1224592)
Based on my reading of the first few pages of the paper (available here http://arxiv.org/abs/0905.2658 ), your description appears roughly correct.

E8 is a lie group, which is a set of matrices which is closed under inversion and multiplication. In fact, E8 is a very large group.

Particle physics is based on a set of smaller groups, but these groups are distinct. A "theory of everything" would embed these smaller groups into a single large group. Lisi showed that you can embed these smaller groups into E8, although he didn't show that all the important properties hold.

Garibaldi showed that there are only 6 ways of doing this embedding which don't create higher spin particles. He then showed that none of these 6 ways preserve chirality (the right-handedness of the universe).

So basically, while the relevant groups can be embedded into E8, they don't preserve the physics necessary for a theory of everything.

Re:Surfer’s ‘everything theory’ wipes out by hristov on Sunday March 28, 2010 @05:14PM (#1225241)
Good job figuring out the paper, but if you had to read the paper, that just proves my initial point that the analogy failed.