Re:On Post-Modernist Philosophy of Science (2000)
by wpietri on Monday August 08, 2016 @01:27AM
(#12245659)
I don't have much opinion on the rest of your translation, but I think this gets it wrong:
> Postmodernists make for shitty programmers
To me one of the big differences with postmodernism is a deep skepticism for grand overarching theories and perfect understandings. I think that's an immensely useful trait for a programmer.
The more I code, the more I treat any digital representation as a deeply distorted image of the reality I'm dealing with. The best I can do is have the distortions match my user's purpose. As Box wrote, "All models are wrong; some models are useful." The modernist continues to seek the perfect model. The postmodernist treats perfection as a fool's errand and ships something that works well enough.
I have seen this problem over and over in my career; a lot of architecture astronautics strikes me as rooted in modernism. But perhaps a good example that everybody can look at is early concepts of AI vs today's machine learning. When I compare Cyc [1], which has spent 30 years trying to build the seeds of perfect knowledge versus today's deep learning, that strikes me as a postmodern shift.
How does a convolutional neural network recognize a dog? We don't exactly know, not in a way that makes much sense to us. [2] But we don't care. The convnet has its own very bounded, limited version of "truth"; as long as we get a 90% match, we ship it and go out for beers.
> Postmodernists make for shitty programmers
To me one of the big differences with postmodernism is a deep skepticism for grand overarching theories and perfect understandings. I think that's an immensely useful trait for a programmer.
The more I code, the more I treat any digital representation as a deeply distorted image of the reality I'm dealing with. The best I can do is have the distortions match my user's purpose. As Box wrote, "All models are wrong; some models are useful." The modernist continues to seek the perfect model. The postmodernist treats perfection as a fool's errand and ships something that works well enough.
I have seen this problem over and over in my career; a lot of architecture astronautics strikes me as rooted in modernism. But perhaps a good example that everybody can look at is early concepts of AI vs today's machine learning. When I compare Cyc [1], which has spent 30 years trying to build the seeds of perfect knowledge versus today's deep learning, that strikes me as a postmodern shift.
How does a convolutional neural network recognize a dog? We don't exactly know, not in a way that makes much sense to us. [2] But we don't care. The convnet has its own very bounded, limited version of "truth"; as long as we get a 90% match, we ship it and go out for beers.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyc
[2] https://blog.keras.io/how-convolutional-neural-networks-see-...