Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living
by ruste on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:11AM
(#12232436)
The rich aren't just sitting on a giant pile of liquid assets. Basically all of their money is invested. It's circulating right now. It's the infrastructure and businesses the poor are buying from. You can't redistribute wealth like that because if you do there quickly won't be services to buy from. You don't improve a poor mans situation by dismantling the grocery store he goes to. Even if you give him a slice of what you take, you've removed infrastructure that he relies on. He'll be set for a week or two, but when he needs to buy food again the grocery store won't be able to provide the way it used to.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living
by prostoalex on Friday August 05, 2016 @12:41PM
(#12233728)
> if you were rich before the money will obviously keep coming back, as more people have the wealth to purchase your services
In a scenario where the original rich person was a landlord, factory owner or a farmer, the property progressively got taken away to cover the tax bills and either sold to a bunch of third parties or just taken over by a government agency, as those property auctions take a while to set up, find respective buyers and run.
The "services" thesis works for someone charging per engagement, like a doctor, as they can probably operate with relatively small overhead, but for a bunch of occupations the property that's responsible for building wealth is also the tool of building that wealth.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living
by aleksei on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:49PM
(#12234349)
Obviously with absurd property taxes this would be an issue.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living
by collyw on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:46PM
(#12234847)
Rob outright? Do you really believe that billionaires create so much value for the world (because they can't work hard enough to justify their exceptional wealth)? Mark Zuckerburgs contributions were more valuable than Tim Berners Lee?
2) What do you think happens to the money, that it gets burned? The money will continue in circulation (ie. the previously poor will now pay for their food instead of stealing it etc.), and if you were rich before the money will obviously keep coming back, as more people have the wealth to purchase your services.