Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living
by prostoalex on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:05AM
(#12230351)
Good point, I misread on mutual exclusivity.
For what it's worth high estate taxes don't seem to correlate with economic growth (neither are zero estate taxes, to be fair) - I am reading this graph http://taxfoundation.org/article/estate-and-inheritance-taxe... and Japan, for example, being high on the GDP ranking is kinda dead in the water as far as economic growth ranking.
I think eventually the estates succumb to "three generations" rule, so the problem might be self-correcting.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living
by morgante on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:07AM
(#12230360)
My argument isn't necessarily an economic one. I don't particularly think that a high estate tax will stimulate the economy, but I also don't think it will hurt.
The advantage of a high estate tax is more a social one of removing unearned wealth and freeing up some money to spend on social programs.
But you're right that it might be more efficient to make the tax 95% so the beneficiary has an incentive to handle the liquidation so they can get their 5%.
The stability of capital is in fact a huge part of how NY/CA remain successful—if you're ambitious, you have to move towards the capital to access it.
Also, keep in mind we're in the context of a thread where people are already discussing how to soak the rich. I'd much rather tax estates than dramatically increase taxes for people who have earned their money.