News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by NhanH on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:03AM (#12230162)
> We already know how to cut poverty, based on other countries like the Nordics where poverty is lower: Take more from the rich and give more to the poor. Unfortunately, rich people love money too much, so we're not allowed to talk about the real solution, and have to talk about all these fake solutions instead.

We don't talk about the real solution because none of the person that want to "take more from the rich and give more to the poor" proposes one. The problem isn't what to do, but how to do it.

Courtesy of being born in a Communist country, I had to learn Karl Marx and such in middle school. And almost every single statement on this comment chain reads like my term exam questions (I'm not being facetious here). He has a whole chapter on general formula of capital, and another one on rent seeking behavior. It's all good idea ... until you actually try to implement it and the resulting government is nuts.

Take those with 100% inheritance tax idea. Are you gonna also tax gift at 100%? Cause it's obvious what will happen. Now we're adding special case that parents are not allowed to gift their house to their children?

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:18AM (#12230943)
>We don't talk about the real solution because none of the person that want to "take more from the rich and give more to the poor" proposes one.

That's just a lie. I could reel off about 20 or 30, many of which were the centerpiece of a presidential campaign.

* Raise minimum wage.

* Implement 100% LVT.

* Water down intellectual property laws.

* Water down laws that attack unions (e.g. 'right' to work).

* Strengthen laws that allow unions to organize.

* Remove carried interest rule.

* Implement a job guarantee.

* Make trade deals with other countries contingent on ^^^ this stuff happening in those countries too.

Unfortunately, left economists who can make a case for policies like this are consistently shouted down by the 'respectable' economists who predict austerity will cause growth 7 years in a row (any day now!) and catastrophic job losses will be the only result of raising the minimum wage. Those who make being usefully wrong a profession, in other words.

>Courtesy of being born in a Communist country, I had to learn Karl Marx and such in middle school. And almost every single statement on this comment chain reads like my term exam questions (I'm not being facetious here). He has a whole chapter on general formula of capital, and another one on rent seeking behavior. It's all good idea ... until you actually try to implement it and the resulting government is nuts.

98% of his writings were a critique of capitalism. He didn't provide a detailed description of how to implement anything.

Of course, some dictators used his writings as a pretext to seize power and implement fairly bog standard authoritarian regimes and guilt by association works wonders on the feeble minded, so there's that

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by NhanH on Friday August 05, 2016 @07:30AM (#12231426)
> 98% of his writings were a critique of capitalism. He didn't provide a detailed description of how to implement anything.

Yeah that's exactly my point. The issue is when we try to turn all those seemingly "good" things into practice, we couldn't figure out how.

Let me pick the one that I disagree the most in your list:

> Implement a job guarantee

How would you do that?

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Friday August 05, 2016 @09:19AM (#12232067)
>Yeah that's exactly my point. The issue is when we try to turn all those seemingly "good" things into practice, we couldn't figure out how.

He wrote a critique of capitalism

Das Kapital was not a list of seemingly good thing that could be turned into practice. The fact that other people read the book and did misguided or horrible things is no reflection on what he wrote.

>>>Let me pick the one that I disagree the most in your list:

>>Implement a job guarantee

>How would you do that?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Works_Administration

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Works_Progress_Administration

If you think the Lincoln Tunnel was a waste of money and you think that the private sector overproducing shoddy McMansions where nobody wants to live in 2007 was a great thing then you probably wouldn't be a fan.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by matt_wulfeck on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:11AM (#12230181)
Reminds me of this:

The poor spendthrift vagabond says to a rich man:

"I have discovered there is enough money in the world for all of us, if it was equally divided; this must be done, and we shall all be happy together."

"But," was the response, "if everybody was like you, it would be spent in two months, and what would you do then?"

"Oh! divide again; keep dividing, of course!"

https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/www/barnum/moneygetting/

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by djrobstep on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:32AM (#12230253)
This anecdote is dumb and wrong, but is a handy way to call poor people trash when you're afraid to say so directly, I guess.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by JanezStupar on Friday August 05, 2016 @03:40AM (#12230638)
And yet, that is precisely the argumentation one usually gets when proposing the "running out of other people's money" dilemma.

A case in point: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zmji36q8E4o

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by vixen99 on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:52AM (#12230316)
If I say the anecdote is perceptive and right you'd expect me to give reasons wouldn't you especially if I add an unpleasantly tendentious opinion?
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by throwaway049 on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:58AM (#12230517)
I think it is wrong because the people advocating cutting the pie differently are not poor, spendthrift vagabonds but people with jobs who believe that they are not getting a fair cut of the wealth they create.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by matt4077 on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:47AM (#12230852)
In many cases, they are even people who stand to pay more if they get their wish. You don't have to personally profit from a certain policy to advocate it.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by JanezStupar on Friday August 05, 2016 @03:38AM (#12230630)
And their act of believing automatically makes it true and justified?

That is called narcissism.

From my anecdotal experience it is too often people who are themselves near or at 1% trying to justify how the "rich" are taking something away from them.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by Pyxl101 on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:18AM (#12230764)
> I think it is wrong because the people advocating cutting the pie differently are not poor,

You mean, the people who are advocating for taking someone else's pie.

Where does this idea come from that the rich are "taking" from them? No one takes from you, except for the government when they collect taxes. All other relationships are consensual relationships negotiated by people who are all looking for the best deal they can find. Someone pays me for my labor, and in return for compensation I give them my labor. It's a fair deal and entered willingly. If I did not think it was a fair deal, then I could offer my labor to someone else and look for a better one, or I could start my own business and work for myself.

If you think that someone else is taking from you or paying an unfair price, then start your own business. You might end up with a different perspective on the value that business owners and capitalists have in society. When you start a business, all of the wealth you create is done with your own hand: you provide a product or service, and you convince people to give you their money in exchange for it. They do, and (hopefully) you end up with more money than it costs to create the product or service, and so you profit. The difference is, no one is taking care of you by saying, "Hey, just come into work every day and we'll pay you." The business owner needs to make sure its suppliers deliver product on time, and its clients pay what they owe on time, and handle various sorts of concerns that are easy to fail to recognize. The business owner needs to make sure their facilities are operational, and that laborers have the tools and supplies they need to do the job, otherwise work stops! There's a chance that your business can crash and you'll be left with nothing. You take on a risk that you work for years and end up with essentially nothing, because your company might be running out of money, and no one might be willing to buy your (at that point) failing, borderline worthless company. There's a lot of risk involved, especially in companies that develop new products -- the value of the product isn't known, and so you're taking on a risk that the company itself might collapse due to being immature, and a further risk that the product might not be valuable, and many more risks.

If anyone be believes that they or someone are "not getting a fair cut", then they are welcome to strike out on their own or with like minded people and create their own organization. This website frequently writes about organizations that were created by just a few people, delivered incredible value, and so grew into something great.

Furthermore, if this company founder is correct in their theory that organizations that employ laborers are not giving the laborers a fair share, then the new company that they found will be able to and will choose to pay laborers much more than any competitor will (due to recognizing their true value). In paying more for the labor, this company will be able to attract by far the best laborers and hire as many people as it needs. Competitors meanwhile will be starved for talent and will suffer. In this way, a company that fairly values and fairly compensates the work produces by its laborers will out-compete companies that undervalue their laborers. In the end, companies that value worker labor correctly will come out on top.

If you have studied economics, and you have followed this reasoning, then you should be open to the possibility that laborers are in fact fairly compensated for the value they produce. That's not to say that we should not have progressive taxes, but when you recognize this, you might look differently at the idea that peoples' value is being "stolen". They're willingly trading it at a price they negotiated. You shouldn't be sour about a deal you negotiated and accepted; and you shouldn't be mad at someone that a better deal isn't available. Perhaps I think I should be paid $1 million dollars per year, but just because I believe that doesn't make it true. A person deserves to have the compensation that they earn by providing value to others, at a rate the other people agree to willingly (and enough to say alive, whichever is greater).

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by enraged_camel on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:14AM (#12230751)
It's a wrong and dumb anecdote because spending money doesn't make it vanish into thin air. It just ends up in someone else's pocket. And from there, one can indeed "keep dividing" as the poor man suggested.

It seems the poor man in that story knows more about how the economy works than the rich man.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by manicdee on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:27AM (#12230234)
Implying that the only difference between rich and poor is spending habits.

Where in the real world we have confounding factors such as racism, sexism, cultural norms, differing costs of transit and habitation, limited opportunities and limits on resources.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by _andromeda_ on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:38AM (#12230268)
It seems to me like it's the only one that matters because it's the one that an individual has the most control over. Other confounding factors are externalities that as an individual you cannot always control but guess what you can always do? Save, save, save and if you can, innovate and reap the fruits of your discipline and hard work.

Collectivism should be avoided.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:52AM (#12231046)
>It seems to me like it's the only one that matters

You literally have to do nothing to cash a rent check, receive share dividends or interest on a loan.

From a systems' perspective that's parasitism.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by JanezStupar on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:30AM (#12231182)
You are simplifying to the level of dishonesty.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:57AM (#12231281)
There's really no other way to characterize non-gift exchanges of wealth that the recipient did not create.

The only thing that stops this system of parasitic wealth transfer from spinning out of control is re-redistributive taxation.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by _andromeda_ on Friday August 05, 2016 @08:40AM (#12231782)
>The only thing that stops this system of parasitic wealth transfer from spinning out of control is re-redistributive taxation.

At least we're in agreement that parasitism is not a desirable outcome. We seem to disagree on what constitutes parasitic behavior.

First of all, I think that the idea of estate tax is lunacy in and of itself but now that we have it, let's think about what you're saying; that it's not okay for an individual upon death to transfer his/her wealth to a person of their choosing (whom they may have mentored to further a legacy they were passionate about) but that it is okay for the proletariat to forcibly acquire said wealth because they know better?

How is that not outright theft? I would like the opportunity to freely determine how my acquired wealth will be spent after I'm dead. If I would like to leave it to a mentee of mine to further some work I had began, then being the acquirer of said wealth, I deserve that right.

You know, this experiment is already done and dusted. Any time you advocate for egalitarianism, look at the results of "The Berlin Wall's great human experiment" then be afraid. What sort of government shoots its own people to prevent them from running away from the horrid conditions they've created? I'll tell you which one, a socialist/communist one.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Friday August 05, 2016 @09:00AM (#12231919)
>How is that not outright theft?

It's re-redistributive. Taxation somewhat compensates for the redistributive effect of the rentier economy, which you could also characterize as theft for similar reasons.

>I would like the opportunity to freely determine how my acquired wealth will be spent after I'm dead

And I would like not to have to dedicate 40% of my income to renting property from non-productive (sometimes anti-productive) members of society.

Euthananize the rentier and I'll be happy for you to keep 100% of the wealth you earned with actual work.

Until that time, no.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by ruste on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:03AM (#12232379)
That non-productive/anti-productive member of society is the one that keeps your appliances running, makes sure your roof isn't leaking, and fixes your pipes when they leak. They're not just sitting back and watching the money role in. Managing property, moreover doing so profitably, is not a kick back and relax kind of job. You're welcome to buy and maintain your own property if you'd like. It would cost you about as much in the long run.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:28AM (#12232556)
>That non-productive/anti-productive member of society is the one that keeps your appliances running, makes sure your roof isn't leaking, and fixes your pipes when they leak.

No, that's called a property management company. Around where I live they take ~10% of the rent and pass the rest on to the rentier.

Try again.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by ruste on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:33PM (#12234201)
Nope, rent management companies generally take a cut for doing the _Management_ portion. That means drawing up forms, selecting renters, doing background checks etc. The landlord still has to pay for or do repairs. I wouldn't be surprised if some management companies will arrange for repairs to be done as part of what they do, but it still comes out of the landlords pocket.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Sunday August 07, 2016 @11:58AM (#12242418)
In some markets they tend not to do repairs, in some they do.

If you were being generous you could argue that landlords lose another 10% of the rent to repairs.

That still leaves a big fat 80% slice of the rents coming in which is free money.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by ruste on Monday August 08, 2016 @09:27AM (#12247511)
More like 20% if you don't include labour. Then take out another 40-50% for insurance on the property. Then put the rest into paying the mortgage. Which you admittedly get back, but remember you're doing all the work on the house yourself and houses do wear out over time so that will eat into your margin even more.

EDIT: Don't forget about property taxes! Those eat up a pretty big chunk of the rent too. They're usually a couple hundred a month. Let's be nice and call that 10% although it's generally much larger.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by antisthenes on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:41PM (#12234809)
The problem with this is that even if you only just break even as a rent-seeker, you're still creating wealth for yourself and reducing the market of available properties for potential buyers, creating massive negative externalities.

Landlords are doubly parasites.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by ruste on Friday August 05, 2016 @03:09PM (#12235015)
>even if you only just break even as a rent-seeker, you're still creating wealth for yourself

That sounds utterly contradictory.

Landlords provide a service by maintaining and managing properties. They assume most of the risks including damage to the property due to fire and natural disasters. They provide a means for people with little to no credit to afford a roof over their head when they can't get a loan. You are not just paying to live somewhere when you pay rent. You are paying for all of these services and more. If landlords were purely parasites they wouldn't be able to make any money. People would just go around them. Just because you don't like the need for the service they provide doesn't mean they don't provide a service.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Sunday August 07, 2016 @12:11PM (#12242456)
>Landlords provide a service by maintaining and managing properties.

We already established that property management companies do this for 10% of the rent.

>They assume most of the risks including damage to the property due to fire and natural disasters.

Should I charitably assume that you've just never heard of insurance?

>They provide a means for people with little to no credit

That 80% of the rent which goes into their pockets after management, insurance and repairs are taken care of is pure, unadulterated parasitism.

Just as payday loans are parasitism.

They both effect net transfers of wealth that, similar to a payday loan. Capitalism grants an entitlement to those with more money to receive an income only because they have more money.

>You are paying for all of these services and more

You are often paying and not even getting these services. Many landlords end up not fixing stuff that breaks.

>If landlords were purely parasites they wouldn't be able to make any money. People would just go around them.

Not possible while they own deeds to the land. Ownership of the land is the part that lets them be parasites.

>Just because you don't like the need for the service they provide doesn't mean they don't provide a service.

Owning land is what gives them the ability to provide a service and charge 5x what it is worth.

If land ownership were illegal and it were simply rented from the government at the exact prevailing unimproved rental value then landlords would become more like an average shop owner rather than massive leeches on productive members of society.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by ruste on Monday August 08, 2016 @09:35AM (#12247568)
>We already established that property management companies do this for 10% of the rent.

Closer to 30% and that doesn't include maintenance costs and insurance which are _VERY_ significant.

>Should I charitably assume that you've just never heard of insurance?

I've been charitable by not bringing it up. It costs ~40-50% of your gross income from a rental property where I'm from.

>That 80% of the rent which goes into their pockets after...

Point me to where I can make that kind of money and I'll quit my job today. I'm sure I would have absolutely NO trouble at all getting a loan if I was pretty much guaranteed an 80% profit.

>Many landlords end up not fixing stuff that breaks.

If it's in the lease that they will (It's in mine.) Then sue them. If not, fix it or move. I've yet to see a lease that didn't include timely repairs.

>If land ownership were illegal and it were simply rented from the government...

It pretty much is. What do you think property taxes are? When you pay for land you're just providing an incentive for another party to cut their lease short.

>Not possible while they own deeds to the land. Ownership of the land is the part that lets them be parasites.

Land is cheap in a lot of places. Sometimes much cheaper than renting. The barrier to buying land varies, but sometimes renting is a better option.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by JanezStupar on Saturday August 06, 2016 @05:13AM (#12237581)
Offering people a service of housing, without having them to deal with the complexities of property purchase, financing, transaction costs, maintenance and whatnot comes with it.

How dare they!

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Sunday August 07, 2016 @12:18PM (#12242473)
Except you can pay somebody to take care of all of the 'complexities' and still make a fat profit. I can't pay somebody to take care of setting up and running a software business and make a guaranteed large profit.

That profit is parasitically extracted. No 'work' was done to actually get it - it's merely the privilege that having money gives you.

Some landlords do do the work themselves, which simply means that not all of the income derived from their properties is parasitically extracted - only ~80%.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by ruste on Monday August 08, 2016 @09:22AM (#12247474)
>fat profit

Probably not. You'll barely break even. It's not as lucrative as you think it is.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by makomk on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:00PM (#12239086)
Instead, they have to deal with the complexities of finding new rental properties and moving on a regular basis in order to keep the rent in check (or just sometimes randomly because their landlord decides to sell up), convincing their landlord to actually do maintenance, put up with the fact that they're not allowed to make any modifications to the property, etc.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by JanezStupar on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:58PM (#12239619)
And life of a landlord is all rainbows and unicorns?

Get real.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by JanezStupar on Friday August 05, 2016 @08:12AM (#12231635)
Your lack of self awareness is incredible.

How are you yourself different from the vilified "rent seeker"?

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Friday August 05, 2016 @08:53AM (#12231866)
Instead of consuming more value than I create, I create more value than I am compensated for. Because I derive my income from my work.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by JanezStupar on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:21AM (#12232495)
And thus you are seeking rent from those with more property than yourself.

Fantastic.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by crdoconnor on Friday August 05, 2016 @10:34AM (#12232603)
People who own yield bearing properties (e.g. landlords - not me) are extracting value from others.

You can spin that fact any way that you want but it's still a fact.

That's why I don't call it redistributive taxation. It's re-redistributive taxation.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by eggy on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:48AM (#12230301)
I agree is it overly simplistic, but even factoring in your list of factors, spending habits are very key. See my other remark up top about financial literacy. The U.S. ranks 6th worldwide in wages, but 25th in wealth, since so many in the US live off of credit, and don't save as much as their Chinese counterparts for one example. Irrespective of populist banter, the top 0.1% pay about 40% of the tax revenue the Federal government collects. I think our tax system is more progressive than popular opinion makes it out to be. If you earn over $450,000 a year, you are in the top 1% by wage.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by matt4077 on Friday August 05, 2016 @04:45AM (#12230848)
Maybe your term paper was about the (excellent!) analysis Marx gave on the failures of capitalism? Because almost all I'm reading, except the comment you replied to, are market-based approaches with a healthy dose of victim-blaming for poverty.

The "nordic model" has actually very little to do with Marxism. Marx didn't write about money, he wrote about power, specifically economic power. Experiments with that idea all failed because it's a very bad idea to randomly give people power (or, as it happened in most of those experiments, give it to the government).

There's a newer idea which people are generally advocating when they mention Scandinavia which so-called "Social democrats" came up with: just redistribute (some of) the money. Leave enough to the wealthy to leave incentives intact, give enough to the poor so they and their children can live a somewhat normal life. I believe it's worked quite well for almost all countries that have tried it.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by NhanH on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:12AM (#12230921)
Money, wealth, economic power are all used mostly synonymous in informal discussion like this, and I don't really like to discuss word semantic right now.

A lot of people on HN is supporting Basic Income policy (I do, too). And that's why I specifically pointed out the extreme hyperbole policy while replying to a very antagonizing comment, it wasn't a critic on the "idea". This is the kind of things that the specific matters and you need to says what exactly you are looking for.

FWIW, when I posted there were much fewer comments, and the sentiment was different than the current top comments.

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by Trundle on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:31AM (#12230246)
Is preventing wealth transfer from parent to child not their goal? In that case one would expect that transferring house from parent to child not being allowed isn't an unwanted side effect but part of the intended one.
Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by NhanH on Friday August 05, 2016 @01:34AM (#12230255)
I'm giving my house to my nephew ... and it just happens that my brother is giving his house to my kid.

How many generations out do you plan to ban? Cause it might be a good time for me to start getting to know my extended cousins. ;)

Re:To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living by qbrass on Friday August 05, 2016 @06:21AM (#12231155)
>How many generations out do you plan to ban?

I'm guessing all of them.

Not that it really changes anything. You'll just put your major assets in other people's name long before you die so the state doesn't take them. If you raised your children right, they won't sell your house while you're still living in it.