Studies show that people have trouble recognizing someone out of context about half the time. In other words, you work with John, you run into him elsewhere. You may not recognize him at all or you may realize you know him, but struggle to say from where.
People who are giving you a hard time about this likely are overestimating their ability to recognize faces. Context significantly influences this.
I wonder if it is actually on a spectrum. I have difficulty, but also can work at it with some success. It was a running joke in our family that I would mis-identify actors on the screen. But eventually I got to be pretty good at spotting certain actors- by studying their facial characteristics.
Re:The super-recognisers of Scotland Yard
by sehutson on Friday August 05, 2016 @02:35AM
(#12230443)
Same here - I don't even recognize my immediate family in a lot of situations. I've had people accuse me of being a snob and pretending not to remember them, but once I know their name I can usually remember a ton of stuff about them and that usually makes them feel better about it.
It's not super uncommon, but a lot of people make it to adulthood without realizing they have it - and some lifestyles make it easier than others.
I thought it is relatively common condition (around 2% of people). But other people seem to be genuinely surprised by it every time: "how could you not recognize me? I have passed directly in front of you?" Sorry.