A similar problem exists with car alarms. What percentage of car alarms going off are in response to a legitimate threat of theft? I would imagine it is in the single digits at the highest. This leads to most people reacting to car alarms with mere annoyance rather than any suspicion of an actual crime.
I don't know a real solution to this. It is really just human nature to react to personal experience and if that experience says alarms are usually wrong, we will begin to ignore them. Meanwhile the makers of the alarms have an incentive to be overly sensitive because a false positive is much less dangerous than a false negative. This results in a sort of tragedy of the commons in which all alarms end up being too prone to trigger accidentally.
I wonder whether this is actually statistically true, if false positives cause true positives to be ignored by some non-trivial proportion of the population? I think it's just as likely this is legal CYA from the alarm makers -- they can only get sued for false negatives, after all.
But, as you might guess, eventually the real deal hits. Back in my firefighting days we had a church in Shallotte that had an automatic alarm that had frequent false alarms. So much so that if that call came in, we would admittedly not hurry go get into turnout gear and get on the rig... we'd lollygag around a minute or two waiting for the inevitable cancellation notice. Then one day, that alarm comes in, and two minutes later dispatch comes back "police office on scene advises smoke showing". Urk!
There's really no easy answer to this though... people are going to be who and how they are. All we can do is try out best to get people to do the right thing.
This happened about 7 blocks away a week or two ago. Older building (1950s, wood and brick), 5 stories, 15 units. Unlike my building (CAL133 compliant cabinets, modern fireproofing, lots of sprinklers) it probably didn't have sprinklers.
It went 6 alarms. If you didn't leave immediately, you would've had no chance to afterwards. Fatalities were probably all but guaranteed for anyone who lacked the wherewithal to get out. Thankfully, folks had the common sense to get out quickly and I believe there weren't even any injuries.
This is the same in offices, in my experience. Our shared office building has a horrible fire system, and gets about a half dozen false fire alarms a year. My coworkers think I'm crazy for always going directly outside when the alarm starts blaring.
Sooner or later, one of those "false alarms" is going to be real and people will still be sitting at their desks while the building is really on fire.
Most people will never in their whole lives experience a real building fire.
It would be much better to make false alarms extremely rare. Perhaps we could do a Toyota-style "five whys" for every single false alarm until the fire alarm in your office is fixed properly.
"Altogether, six people were killed and 1,042 others injured, most during the evacuation that followed the blast."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_World_Trade_Center_bombin...
Hopefully your building is apartments instead of condos. If I lived in such a situation, I'd get out of there ASAP. Nothing's worse then getting pulled out of sexy time because Chicken Little is running around screaming that the sky is falling.
It's not great, but you can see where they're coming from, with 2.5 alarms per year compared to 0.5 fires.
I don't understand. I've experienced probably around a hundred fire alarms in my life and maybe two fires. A 1/5 chance that an alarm means a fire is an excellent reason to leave the apartment every time—That's a terrible rate to justify staying inside.
HiFog - Uses water mist to prevent limit damage:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_NsBZ7oXok
Then you think... Maybe it could be made better?
Which hey, fine, you know better, but how many people from the building have been dragged out of a fire by the fire fighters? For all the people that haven't been rescued, why conclude that their risk assessment is so much worse than yours?
I live in a (modern, 4-floor, built in 2008, steel and concrete) building with 145 apartments. We have about 2 or 3 fire alarms a year because late-20s professionals don’t understand that pouring oil into a pan heated on high for 20 minutes does nothing but generate a massive amount of smoke. Though in 7 years, we’ve had 3 actual fires. One serious enough to pop the glycerin disk of a sprinkler head (and cause ~$1M in water damage from the ~5000 gallons it pumped out before it was turned off, compared to about $20-30K in fire damage).
I am the building’s “unofficial first responder”. I try to find it, so I can direct fire fighters to it when they arrive 8 minutes later, in the hopes of it being dealt with before a sprinkler head pops and makes the lives of many of the units' neighbors miserable for the next few months (because water damage and related insurance claims). Once, management was still here, and we used the skeleton key to access the unit and I actually put it out myself with an extinguisher (and killed the breakers to the stove). As I’m running through the hall, I have to tell people peering out their doors to “get out now, fire alarm”, and that no, they can’t take the elevator (because they’re now parked) and they need to take stairs.
When there are firefighters going into the building, with hoses, and putting up ladders, you have people in neighboring apartments watching... from the windows inside their apartments. Until the fire department knocks on their doors and screams at them, through a megaphone, to get out.
Management commented to me that during the fire alarms with actual fires (which granted, were small), ~30% of people (~80-90 people) refused to leave. That's a hell of a potential burden in the event of a serious fire to put on the firefighters.