Re:Driving dataset for car autopilot AI training
by Animats on Thursday August 04, 2016 @02:33PM
(#12227534)
That's not a hard case. It's just a narrow, straight road lined with obstacles. If you have sensors that can get a height field, that's no problem. Our DARPA Grand Challenge vehicle could have done that in 2005, using a LIDAR. Google wouldn't have any problem with that. Tesla would have a problem; they're dependent on lane lines.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Driving dataset for car autopilot AI training
by ghaff on Thursday August 04, 2016 @02:52PM
(#12227641)
The main difficulty with a side street like that is there isn't actually enough room for 4 vehicles across--2 parked and 2 going in opposite directions. Humans can deal with this pretty easily because it's usually fairly obvious who can most easily yield or even back up a little bit. It's not an especially hard problem and 2 vehicles that could formally communicate would make it easier yet. However, if the behavior depends on essentially social signals, that's somewhat harder but far from impossible to model. (You probably program the computer to politely yield if at all possible.)
However, as you say, this is yet another case where vehicles aren't expected to unthinkingly follow lane lines--if they even exist.
Re:Driving dataset for car autopilot AI training
by taco_emoji on Thursday August 04, 2016 @03:43PM
(#12227944)
The point is that this is a two-way street with (effectively) only one lane, so regardless of how good your sensors are, your AI needs to predict and react to the actions of oncoming cars in order to successfully navigate this road.
Re:Driving dataset for car autopilot AI training
by IshKebab on Saturday August 06, 2016 @05:20AM
(#12237587)
As taco_emoji said, the difficulty is not avoiding the obstacles. What happens if a car is coming the other way. Do you reverse? Do you let them reverse? Did they flash you? Are they waiting in a 2-lane section? Should you wait? What if it's a bike instead - can you both fit?
Way more difficult than "don't hit the sides".