News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by superuser2 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:05PM (#12219526)
Any time ageism comes up on HN, someone trots out "the people who are complaining about being victims of ageism just haven't been keeping their skills up to date; keep learning new things and you will be fine." It generally goes unchallenged. I would consider that to be discounting ageism as nonexistent.
Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @03:47PM (#12220921)
I don't know if I have ever experienced actual ageism. Here's what I've found, though:

- If you want somebody who will work 14-hour days, well, that eliminates most people over 40.

- If you want to pay appropriate to someone who's 25, well, that eliminates most people over 40.

- If your company is a pit, if your management is insane, if your coworkers are psychopaths, well, most people over 40 have seem that enough times to not go there.

I've seen companies advertising for "senior software engineer". They want 5-7 years of experience. I've got 30. They don't want to pay for 30. Is that ageism? Or am I just too expensive? Or does my experience exceed the hiring manager's ability to correctly value?

I'm not saying that ageism doesn't exist. But I am saying that there are some reasons other than ageism that older software engineers find it harder to get hired.

Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by morgante on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:49PM (#12222111)
Tech is, ultimately, an up or out field.

The marginal return to experience is minimal after a decade or so, particularly when it comes to the average software job. If you have decades of experience, you need to be in a higher leverage position (either consulting or management) to get appropriate pay for the position.

This doesn't make tech ageist. My local grocery store also doesn't pay the senior cashiers any more than the high school ones.

Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:55PM (#12222152)
I disagree, at least for some sub-fields. In embedded systems, 20 years of experience is more valuable than 5 years (and has pay to reflect that).

In web programming? Maybe not so much...

Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by morgante on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:57PM (#12222158)
It sounds like we actually agree. Most of the accusations of ageism seem to be for fields where 20 years of experience is not so valuable.
Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @09:03PM (#12222679)
That makes sense.

If all you need is someone with a few years' experience, the younger candidates are probably going to be willing to work longer hours, for less money, than the older candidates.

In other words, why pay a 20+ year veteran a lot of money to do Rails programming when a recent college grad knows enough to do a decent job, and can be paid an entry-level salary? Not every engineer on a team needs to be senior.

I suspect this is also good career advice: if you don't want to compete with entry-level programmers for jobs, specialize in an area where more experience makes you a more desirable job candidate.

Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @08:13PM (#12222486)
> Most of the accusations of ageism seem to be for fields where 20 years of experience is not so valuable.

I don't have enough data/experience to confirm that, but it seems plausible.

Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by sanderjd on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @08:50PM (#12222641)
Can you articulate why experience is valuable in embedded systems and why it is not valuable in web applications?
Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by linkregister on Thursday August 04, 2016 @05:17AM (#12224360)
Mind that the parent poster didn't claim that experience was not valuable in web applications; just that there were diminished returns.

Embedded systems programming is far more architecture and device specific than web applications are, thankfully. Embedded systems programming requires a much large body of knowledge: chipsets and their features, device-specific options, the behavior of the RTOS (if there is one), esoteric configurations in the cross-compiler or build tool, ability to interactively debug (read the instruction set, use the interface (JTAG, etc), cope with interrupts), ability to thrive with extreme resource limits, and write comprehensive tests with a nearly-exhaustive test plan; since a final release can't be rolled back once customers have purchased it.

This isn't because of some inherent superiority or prestige of embedded systems programming (salaries are lower across the board compared to backend applications programmers), it's just plain more complicated.

A 20-year senior backend programmer should really have progressed to an architect or principal engineer role at that point in her career. An embedded systems developer with 20 years of experience is more typical because of its inherent complexity.

Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by elliotec on Thursday August 04, 2016 @01:44AM (#12223634)
Ageism.
Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by elliotec on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @08:34PM (#12222572)
You don't think having been programming for the web since the web came into existence is not valuable experience to being a web programmer?

That is absurd. That kind of bullshit talk is why ageism exists and what perpetuates it.

Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @08:58PM (#12222663)
He didn't say it wasn't valuable. He said it might not be more valuable than 5 years' experience, presumably because technologies change so quickly in web programming. I don't agree with that, but he certainly wasn't being ageist.
Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by jpindar on Thursday August 04, 2016 @09:23PM (#12229540)
Assuming that anyone over a certain age is going to require short hours, high pay, etc. IS ageist.
Re:Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat? by elliotec on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @08:21PM (#12222517)
One or two gen-xers or millennials saying such things per ageism comment on HN might count as discounting ageism as nonexistent but only by those people specifically.

People know it's a problem. Whether or not they actually do anything about it is a different story. Like any "ism."