News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Over 100 different versions of Avatar were shipped to the... by philwelch on Friday March 26, 2010 @03:32PM (#1221858)
You're talking about promotion. Equating "marketing" with "promotion" is a common misconception. Promotion is part of marketing, but so are place, pricing, and (at least some aspect of)[2] product development. [1] When you're talking about adapting a film to different languages and different screen formats, you're talking about product and place. You're still talking about marketing.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marketing_mix#Four_Ps

[2] Obviously product development in most fields contains a lot of engineering, design, filmmaking, etc. It's pretty fuzzy, but the kind of stuff in this article--adapting to different screen sizes and languages--is definitely on the marketing side.

Re:Over 100 different versions of Avatar were shipped to the... by pchristensen on Friday March 26, 2010 @03:42PM (#1221890)
Would you consider i18n marketing? That's how I see this 100 version effort.
Re:Over 100 different versions of Avatar were shipped to the... by philwelch on Friday March 26, 2010 @04:01PM (#1221930)
Internationalizing software is an engineering effort to fulfill a marketing objective: namely, extending placement into foreign countries.

When you internationalize a film, there's a bit of "filmmaking" (in that you have to have voice actors dubbing the original film, or you have to have translators rewriting your dialogue) but unless Cameron's more multilingual than I thought, I rather doubt directing all those voice actors and supervising those subtitle writers was any artistic effort on his part. His input was a marketing input: I want my film dubbed and subbed into dozens of languages and shown on half a dozen different screen types. (Cameron's not the first director to film with multiple aspect ratios in mind, nor is he the first to make the artistic call of having different aspect ratios, but I'm sure it affected the filmmaking.)

I didn't mean to take away from his studio's technical chops. Avatar's raised the bar for special effects, distribution, and pioneering new screen formats. But it's not a "labor of love", it's just well executed business.