Re:Startups Get Hit By Shrapnel In The Banking Bill
by anigbrowl on Friday March 26, 2010 @02:04PM
(#1221634)
A valid opinion, but let's not forget that this is a worst-case scenario from an interested party. I might note in contrast that the SEC has considered this change before and decided against it after public consultation.
Now, asking them to review it again in the wake of a serious financial crisis might result in the effects described, but then again it might not. I don't think that the idea of re-examining the regulatory environment is inherently bad. Capital formation is not being singled out, just reviewed as part of a comprehensive regulatory overhaul.
And yes, I do support a comprehensive regulatory overhaul, which is not the same thing as a general increase in complexity or strictness. It might even result in simplification of regulation by clarifying some of the ambiguity in existing regulation (bear in mind that regulation D was itself written in the wake of a severe recession). Our financial system has been at the epicenter of a truly severe crisis and I think it's quite appropriate to re-examine the rules it operates under.
Re:Startups Get Hit By Shrapnel In The Banking Bill
by skmurphy on Friday March 26, 2010 @06:01PM
(#1222143)
I think most folks on Hacker News are interested parties. These three sections seem completely unrelated to any of the problems in our financial system.
Now, asking them to review it again in the wake of a serious financial crisis might result in the effects described, but then again it might not. I don't think that the idea of re-examining the regulatory environment is inherently bad. Capital formation is not being singled out, just reviewed as part of a comprehensive regulatory overhaul.
And yes, I do support a comprehensive regulatory overhaul, which is not the same thing as a general increase in complexity or strictness. It might even result in simplification of regulation by clarifying some of the ambiguity in existing regulation (bear in mind that regulation D was itself written in the wake of a severe recession). Our financial system has been at the epicenter of a truly severe crisis and I think it's quite appropriate to re-examine the rules it operates under.