News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by erdevs on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @09:22PM (#12214861)
Tragic and unfortunate, all around.

I wonder what FB's policy on this will be going forward. In many ways, these livestreams are a public good and provide transparency and additional accountability in these situations. If people elect to stream them, it seems wrong to shut it down. On the other hand, perhaps there is a public good in not showing an ongoing live police operation?

I think I'd lean toward not agreeing to shutdown such streams, unless perhaps it's a hostage situation or terror event of some kind. (Getting into squishy definitions there, I'm sure, which is why I qualify it provisionally.)

As to this particular incident... I wish the deceased hadn't resisted. It seems in this case the police exercised much more caution and restraint than has been the case in many other recent examples of shootings. And I think one thing generally stands: if you threaten to kill a police officer and especially if you do so while holding a weapon (or certainly pointing it at them), you're likely to be shot.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by imglorp on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:31PM (#12215165)
> perhaps there is a public good in not showing an ongoing live police operation?

Fair enough, but maybe just delay any posts of an active operation, instead of censoring them?

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by erdevs on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @11:03PM (#12215278)
That seems like a really good suggestion, if it were decided that it's in the public interest not to show some situations live.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by walrus01 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:02AM (#12215706)
From a Facebook abuse and law enforcement operations perspective, if this happens more often it will become a huge pain in the ass. They have procedures in place to provide geolocation and such for urgent subpoenas and warrants (example: a kidnapping in progress). The level of stress that the FB team responsible for this ticket queue must experience is immense.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by tamana on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:06AM (#12215931)
It's a strange wish, because the only reason the police were intertsted in arresting her on Aug 1 was because she steadfastly rejected and resisted police authority previously. This was specifically a micro (idiot) rebellion against govt authority, there were no other (non-derivative) issues involved.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by HelloImDumb on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @09:45PM (#12214971)
This was a hostage situation. Was the 5 year old boy, not a hostage to his crazed, gun-wielding mother in this standoff?

I love Monday morning quarterbacks.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by erdevs on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:51PM (#12215244)
Are you saying that I'm Monday morning quarterbacking? I was trying to ask questions and share possible approaches, without saying anything definitively prescriptive.

A Monday Morning Quarterback doesn't leave a lot of question or uncertainty. That's the kind of the point. They take potshots post facto and frame what "should've" been done as obvious or what happened as ridiculous/blatantly stupid. I don't see how my comment can reasonably be read that way.

I'd ask that you either explain your rude remark in rational terms, or apologize if you don't think you have a great rationale.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by Grishnakh on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @10:43AM (#12218244)
Well, his username is "HelloImDumb"....
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by erdevs on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:54PM (#12215259)
I don't know. Is a child under their mother's care considered a hostage in standoff circumstances? I have no idea. And note that my question was on whether it being a hostage situation should affect the policy or not... so I'm open to the possibility that it was, obviously.

Also, you didn't at all address the question about whether it makes sense to stop streamings in the event of a police encounter or not. If not, when shouldn't it be allowed? I think, at least in many states, you do have the right to record police encounters, especially if it's on your own private property or in a public place. But maybe I'm mistaken?

Perhaps you can read more carefully, think more carefully, behave more civilly, and try again.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by throwaway201607 on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:05PM (#12215052)
>I love Monday morning quarterbacks.

honest question, what does this mean?

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by nstj on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:44PM (#12215211)
> Monday morning quarterback: A person who analyzes the mistakes they made they day after they've made them. Derived from complaining over quarterbacks on monday morning after the sunday game. [0]

[0]: http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=monday%20morn...

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by nocarrier on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:10PM (#12215077)
People who watch a football game Sunday night and then talk shit at work on Monday about all the things they would have done differently if they were coach/quarterback/etc.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by chipperyman573 on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:10PM (#12215079)
Might have something to do with this[0]

>The definition of a Monday morning quarterback is someone who is always criticizing and saying how he would have done something better or differently after the event has passed.

[0] http://www.yourdictionary.com/monday-morning-quarterback

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by dghughes on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:41PM (#12215201)
It's a polite way of calling someone a know-it-all.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by vermontdevil on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:37PM (#12215186)
Same meaning as hindsight is 20/20.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by panic on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:09PM (#12215076)
The police could have left her alone and come back later. They were in her house, and she was only threatening to harm the officers, not her child.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:03AM (#12216853)
If she had shot herself, or her child, or one of her neighbors, while she was in an unstable mental state, people would be outraged that the police had not done anything to prevent it.

It's also intolerable in a society with the rule of law that someone could opt out of being subject to the law by waving a gun around and refusing to comply with a lawful order from the police. If that worked, everyone would do it. It would be impossible to enforce the law.

If she didn't have a child with her, maybe they could have waited her out. They had already been there for quite a while before they decided to act. But to suggest that they just walk away and come back later is absurd.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by panic on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @07:05AM (#12217097)
Sure, but isn't it just as intolerable in a society with the rule of law that people are executed without a trial? There have been lengthy standoffs between the police and people trying not to pay their taxes (Google "police standoff taxes" for lots of examples; here's one: https://www.policeone.com/standoff/articles/1805292-It-was-l...). These standoffs don't typically end in death for the person under arrest.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @07:20AM (#12217160)
When the police shoot someone who shoots at them, or threatens the lives of others, it is not reasonable to classify that as an execution.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by lsaferite on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @09:06AM (#12217630)
I find it interesting that serving such warrants is done in the home vs. catching them outside. It seems like backing someone into a familiar corner (their home) would be like backing a wild animal into it's den.
[dead]
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by erdevs on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @11:04PM (#12215284)
You know that being confrontational and absolutist doesn't help anything and is part of the reason why it's hard to have discussions like this in a reasonable way nowadays, right? Goes with the territory if this is Facebook, or reddit, or Twitter, I guess. But let's keep the insults, pigeonholing, and irrational black-and-white thinking off of HN.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by panic on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:57PM (#12215269)
I think you misunderstand me: I'm not trying to say what the police should have done. I'm just saying it's not a hostage situation.

It's also worth thinking about what factors lead someone to become "crazed", and whether killing them is the right way to deal with the problem.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:53PM (#12215250)
If we've got data let's go with the data, if all we've got is opinions let's go with mine.

Where's the data? We'll probably never know because the police never (rarely?) back down.

And we (society in general) probably aren't prepared to carry out the experiment, but it would be an interesting experiment.

You're right though, the Monday Morning Quaterbacks would criticise LEO regardless. Probably.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by donatj on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:51PM (#12215241)
Answer me this. Honestly. Is people getting served really more important than people's lives?
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by will_brown on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:14AM (#12215749)
>Is people getting served really more important than people's lives?

She wasn't just being served court documents, the police were executing a bench warrant, meaning the police were there to bring her into jail. Moreover, the officers went into this knowing this woman was charged with 4 misdemeanors including resisting arrest, and then she didn't go to court and that is why they were there. Execution of bench warrants is one of the most dangerous jobs of law enforcement, even against non-violent defendants, its probably not good policy to tell officers to execute bench warrants...unless defendants threaten you with violence, in which case, not only don't bring the defendant to jail on the bench warrant but don't charge them with the new crime either.

It would be like saying, is giving a seat belt ticket more important than lives? Of course not, but that doesn't mean pulling a gun on an office is your way out of a traffic ticket.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by tamana on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:11AM (#12215952)
If executing a bench warrant is so dangerous, maybe police should be more careful about how they serve them. For example, surveil the target and approach when the target is not holding a gun.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by will_brown on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @04:52AM (#12216597)
Yeah it would be great if police had resources so they could do surveillance for every defendant who is issued a bench warrant for failing to show up to court. Alternatively, it would be even better if the defendant's saved us all those tax payer dollars and a) showed up to their court hearings, or b) turned themselves after they were mailed the warrant and remove the need for the police to execute the warrant.

Unfortunately, unlimited police funding and hoping all defendants appear in court/surrender themselves are not real solutions. To put the issue in perspective, take the State of NY, at any given time there are going to be well over 1,000,000 open arrest warrants. At that scale even with all the resources and all the care in the World, police are not going to eliminate either officer or defendant deaths completely when warrants are executed. Just look at the society we live in, this defendant was being encouraged in real-time on Facebook to do something that ultimately resulted in her death and the child being shot. As a side I would really like to see these the alleged posts encouraging her not to surrender peacefully, depending on exactly what was said these individuals could in theory be charged with significant crimes themselves.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by 2bitencryption on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @03:58AM (#12216371)
At this point the target has proven to be EXTREMELY unstable and is an enormous hazard. The kind of hazard you would call the police on because you would be afraid of them shooting someone.

I guess this shows that people on HN do not understand these situations as much as they think they do.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by labster on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @12:18AM (#12215554)
That's basically the balance that government makes, with the answer typically being "sometimes". Is people's electricity service more important than people who die from air pollution? Is getting on an airplane one hour faster more important than people who die from terrorism? There are no easy answers.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by tedunangst on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @11:38PM (#12215405)
If he's a serial drunk driver, that may be the same thing.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by twblalock on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:11AM (#12216885)
> Is people getting served really more important than people's lives

If the person being arrested is a danger to others, there is no distinction.

This was not about a subpoena being served. This was an arrest warrant.

Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by tamana on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:09AM (#12215943)
Thank you for your Monday morning psychiatric diagnosis of the deceased's mental state.
Re:Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff by Sukotto on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:30AM (#12216025)
I downvoted you because I read your comment as needlessly confrontational and possibly trolling.