In other words, forming a pool does not allow otherwise non-accredited investors to get around the accreditation requirements. It does not take them "over the line," to use your phrase.
When buying / selling publicly traded shares, there is enough regulation to reasonably protect people from outright scams.
However, it is not uncommon for someone to "pitch" investment ideas to the public that are simply scams -- anything from straight-up ponzi schemes to simply running off with money never to be found again, etc etc.
Actual scam protection could only be accomplished by licensing adulthood by formal test. The kind of mental child who falls for a Ponzi scheme is doomed to squander their resources if allowed to manage their own affairs.
However, if the relationship becomes more tenuous, and he is not really your friend but a friend of a friend or a random acquaintance, then it might be judged to be a public offering.
The act of getting capital from folks that are under the bar shouldn't damn a startup, there's something wrong with this whole process. We shouldn't stop at just nixing the Dodd bill, we should fix the process of angel investing and pooling resources to back those we trust, even if we don't have net worths over an arbitrary line.
Could a group of people who have net worths under the qualified investor line, pool resources and be considered over the line?