News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by bargl on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @02:22PM (#12211983)
I hate this question. I frequently dodge or outright deny answering it. I won't lie about it, I just say, no you don't get that information.

To dodge this question I say the following: "I'm looking for compensation in the range of xxxx to XXXX. This obviously depends on the benefits packages, for an awesome benefits package you may be closer to xxxx, if your benefits are bad then you'll need to be closer to XXXX."

If they persist I follow up with, "I gave you my range if that isn't enough for you then I'm sorry but I'll have to pass, I don't disclose my current salary to any recruiters."

This has worked really well for me in the past.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by lukejduncan on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @06:05PM (#12213786)
I've followed this advice in the past with mixed results. Some companies do a great job of either respecting this or not asking in the first place. When I interviewed at Uber (a little more than a year back), the recruiter was super persistent. I told them "I understand why you're interested, but it's my personal preference at the advice of personal mentors, not to disclose that information. If we both like each other I'm confident we can find an arrangement that is mutually beneficial." To which the recruiter replied, in person face-to-face, after the 5th time asking: "OK, we can do that. But we have a policy of always making the lowest possible offer to candidates who won't share their compensation information. I just want the best for you." In the end, they very clearly made the lowest possible offer they could and weren't willing to negotiate. It was a cool team, and regardless of if you think they're over-valued a cool company, but it was a very easy "no thank you" for me. That's probably the hardest part of the advice -- you need to be comfortable saying "no" if the negotiation doesn't work out.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by rev_bird on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @06:12PM (#12213827)
> "OK, we can do that. But we have a policy of always making the lowest possible offer to candidates who won't share their compensation information. I just want the best for you."

This makes absolutely no sense to me. "Oh, we can't use previous compensation to effectively lowball this candidate we like, so we'll ineffectively lowball them instead."

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by pluma on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @04:36AM (#12216522)
It makes perfect sense. If an applicant doesn't want to disclose their previous salary and disclosing it is the cultural norm, that indicates a) they're troublemakers (very privacy conscious or what have you), or b) their previous salary was very low.

You probably don't want troublemakers so there's no point in making them a generous offer. And if the previous salary was very low the lowest possible offer is probably not too far off.

It actually incentivises disclosing your previous salary because unless it was lower or as low as the lowest offer, you'll have a better bargaining position.

I'm not saying the reasoning is particularly ethical or nice, just that it is entirely rational.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by rev_bird on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @12:57PM (#12219461)
That's interesting, I hadn't considered it that way. I was looking at it as, "We want this person to work here because they passed our tests, now we wreck the deal for no reason." You're saying the salary disclosure is just one of the tests. Makes sense.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by pluma on Thursday August 04, 2016 @03:05AM (#12223911)
If it's penalised, I'd say it's likely a "test" (or more of a checkmark). But I wouldn't go so far as to say every employer that asks for your previous salary is testing you.

That said, even if you disclose your previous salary that could affect how you are perceived:

* disclosing it at all without hesitation might mark you as either very open (positive) or untrustworthy (negative)

* if the salary is much lower than expected it might indicate you're not as good as you claim (negative) or that you're bad at negotiating (positive?) or that you left because you wanted a bigger salary (negative)

* if the salary is much higher than expected it might indicate you'll make unreasonable demands (negative) or that you're a strong negotiator (negative?) or that you are underselling yourself (positive?)

Again, it entirely depends on the employer and sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by drdeadringer on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @02:51PM (#12220446)
How//Why is being privacy-conscious troublemaking?
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by pluma on Thursday August 04, 2016 @02:52AM (#12223875)
I'm not sure you're aware I'm speaking from the hypothetical position of the kind of company that would penalise candidates for not disclosing their previous salary.

From that perspective it should be obvious: if you're a privacy-minded individual, you'll be a bigger hassle to deal with than someone who's blissfully oblivious to privacy concerns. You might call out technically illegal practices others might be willing to put up with, for example.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by drdeadringer on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:23PM (#12238922)
I have blind-spots of dense thinking. I appreciate your response. In particular...

> You might call out technically illegal practices others might be willing to put up with, for example.

It routinely still amazes me that companies want armies of Yes Men to willingly go forth into that good night at the drop of a paper-clip without so much as a "yes but".

You know what that is? An army of dumb-AI robots, which we already have but not to grand-high scale.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by hobs on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @01:17AM (#12215764)
Because that person values you jumping through hoops to train you to accept future hoop jumping you will inevitably do, and test your hoop jumping ability.

If you dont play ball with bureaucracy, you are punished in the only way they have available.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by rpgmaker on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @12:02AM (#12215499)
When I read that I immediately pictured a (very) pissed mob boss. What an asshole.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by bargl on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @06:25PM (#12213910)
I have experienced this as well.

Quick story. Before I took this advice, I made the mistake of telling a recruiter my salary, and then the recruiter said, yeah I'm not going to give you a 20K raise. The guys on that team were great and the compensation was actually viable, but it was not a good fit overall.

I think any negotiation where you want to walk away with the best deal you have to be willing to let a job go. It's when you want something so bad that you start to loose perspective and take a really bad deal. I say this from personal experience. When I have wanted something really bad I negotiate poorly, but when I come at it from a take it or leave it position I am almost always more happy with the result. It's really hard advice to follow when you really need/want a job especially if it's a big name like Uber.

This advice is also VERY dependent on you being able to negotiate. If the market is down and you can't find a job, you may end up in the 5th interview you don't get because you refused to disclose and guess what? This tactic isn't working. Adapt to the market, but use any leverage you have to secure the best position you can for yourself at a place you will be happy.

I've gone through 4 employers in 4.5 years and I have loved 2 of the last 4. Those were the ones I took because I had time to decide and really vetted them out. I had the power in the negotiations and I stacked the deck in my favor. They were also the biggest pay bumps I'd received.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by teach on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @07:24PM (#12214217)
If you don't mind my asking, if you "loved" two of the places you have worked why have you been through four employers in 4-1/2 years?

I love my current employer, which is why I have stayed there 19 years.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by PhasmaFelis on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @09:31PM (#12214906)
The tech jobs I've worked have ended roughly thus:

  Company went under
  Short-term contract for specific task
  Department downsized
  Short-term contract for specific task
  Department downsized
  Short-term contract for specific task
  Short-term contract for specific task
I have never quit a job since finishing school. I'd have loved to stay on at several of those places for the rest of my career, but that's not how most of the industry works these days. If you've been able to stay at a job you love for 19 years, you're very lucky.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by pc86 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @07:00AM (#12217077)
Even with quick promotions, you are much more likely to end up with a higher salary by moving jobs every 1.5-3 years. I'm 30 and the longest I've been at a job is 21 months. It's never been brought up as a negative and I've got plenty of experience across multiple business domains and companies.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @04:41PM (#12221336)
Yeah, it's pretty much taken as normal these days. I'd still rather have job stability than a sky-high salary, if I was given the choice.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by bargl on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:26PM (#12215152)
One the contract ended. The other I'm still at.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by lukejduncan on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @11:25PM (#12215363)
I used to be super intimidated by negotiation. I recently took a Coursera course that I highly recommend https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation. It's not specific to negotiating job offers, but it helped me become a lot more comfortable with the process just to have a framework to think about the whole thing in. It's a really well put together course too.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by cozuya on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @06:40PM (#12213988)
Wow. It could be 20 years from now and all that's left in tech is Amagoogleapplesoft and I'd still walk out when that was said to my face.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by lukejduncan on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @11:22PM (#12215345)
Yeah fair. It was definitely a very negative sign. Having participated in hiring elsewhere, my assumption was maybe it was just a bad recruiter. Generally, engineering managers have a big input into the offer process and I thought I'd give the process the benefit of the doubt over the bad salesmanship. Plus, at that point, it costs me nothing to hear their offer and make a fully informed decision. Even if I knew I wasn't going to take it, waiting a day for a number is a valuable data point.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by rpgmaker on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @10:06AM (#12217955)
I agree. It's not easy to gracefully walk out of that kind of situation. At that point it was better to just go through the motions and maybe end the interview prematurely.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by piaste on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @06:19AM (#12216929)
> "OK, we can do that. But we have a policy of always making the lowest possible offer to candidates who won't share their compensation information. I just want the best for you."

"OK, you can do that. But I have a policy of always turning down offers that are too low for the role and benefits involved. I just want the best for me."

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by piaste on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @08:48AM (#12217519)
Or alternatively (esprit de l'escalier):

"Sorry, I do not negotiate with terrorists."

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by thomasahle on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @06:40PM (#12213986)
> we have a policy of always making the lowest possible offer to candidates who won't share their compensation information

What does "lowest possible offer" even mean? Lowest wage that you can live off? Lowest wage that anybody else in the company makes? Lowest wage that you'll accept?

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by jghn on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @07:23PM (#12214212)
It probably means that they have salary bands and you're starting at the bottom
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by lukejduncan on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @11:22PM (#12215347)
That's what they meant. And probably said. You can take my quote as a (close) paraphrase.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by pc86 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @07:01AM (#12217083)
Positions (titles) have salary bands. If you're at the top, you typically need a promotion to get anything beyond a COLA.

They're saying that whatever your offered position is, you are at the bottom of the salary band as a matter of principle.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by vivekpreddy on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @02:36PM (#12212134)
I've been recruiting for a few years now, and I've always hated asking how much someone is making currently. Have always found it better to ask "what are your compensation expectations?" Puts the ball in the candidate's court and I prefer asking this early in conversations as to make sure we're aligned and no one wastes each others time.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by dudul on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @02:43PM (#12212210)
Why not disclose the budget you are working with and ask the candidate if it's in line with their expectations?
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by Anasufovic on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @03:38PM (#12212682)
First person to talk numbers generally has the weak hand in the negotiation.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by JamesBarney on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @04:11PM (#12212968)
Most negotiation experts disagree with this advice. The first person who gives a number anchors the conversation to that number. When you name a number you certainly do set a max on negotiation, but you also get to set the starting number. And many negotiation experts think the latter is more valuable than the former.

So they can start off trying to negotiate you down from your max, or up you can spend your time trying to negotiate them up from their min.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by erdevs on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @04:32PM (#12213156)
If you're doing something like selling your startup, you want to set the anchor price, yes. There is such a huge range of outcomes, it's best for you to shoot high (as long as you're comfortable with the risk of scaring the buyer off) as the seller. (Or to start and shoot low as the buyer; with the walkaway risk reversed.)

For something like salary negotiation where results are more well-bounded and there is a lot more commoditization (ie replacements are relatively easy to find, or are perceived to be relatively easy to find), you generally don't want to anchor. An anchor that's way out of whack is easy to shoot down (show comp data). Anchoring slightly high/low doesn't buy you much as there is no real anchor... you're just in the established/known range... and so it's more valuable to see where the counterparty starts off an dplay from there.

There are unique situations / exceptions of course. For example, you might have uniquely valuable skills for a given company (or be able to convince them you do) and therefore move into a less-bounded zone of negotiation, in which making the ask/establishing the anchor would again be a good idea. But for a normal, well-established position, there is literally no benefit in "anchoring" as the bounded range is already fairly well established and that is the anchor.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by gozur88 on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @08:23PM (#12214505)
Still, coming up with that first number is very tricky. A application of mine once reached the salary negotiation phase, and the company asked me what I was expecting. I didn't want to go so high they were insulted, so I took what I thought was a reasonable number and bumped it by 40%.

They said "okay". No negotiation, no fireworks, nothing. I've always wondered what I could have gotten out of them.

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by rogerdpack on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @05:01PM (#12213368)
I guess the fear is that you'll anchor it "lower" than they would have. Example if they are intending to pay 120, and you say "I'm hoping to make 110" they might just come down to 110. But I suppose if you start at your high range that might be in your favor. Some of us (myself included) just don't know what we're worth so it's hard to know how to start the deal...
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by JamesBarney on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @06:55PM (#12214074)
Also if your problem is every time you look for a job people keep on wanting to throw more money at you than you could ask for with a straight face. Well then dang I wish I had that problem :)

This problem is usually because people just set their starting price too low, or aren't firm enough on it. One tactic(I haven't used yet, but I'll try the next time I apply to a job) is ask the hiring manager how selective they are. Many time they'll brag about how hard it is to join their company. They'll say things like "We only accept 1 in 10 developers". Boom now they just admitted that if they were paying fair market value their offer should be about $153k :). [0] This is a great place to start a salary negotiation. Also glassdoor is a good place to find information for where to start a salary negotiation as well.

[0] 80% of devs get paid between $57k(10th %) and $153k(90th %).

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by pc86 on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @07:04AM (#12217089)
Your citation needs a citation.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by JamesBarney on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @11:25AM (#12218619)
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by dopamean on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @05:19PM (#12213504)
That sounds similar to the idea the Overton window[0]. I've thought for a while that I hope I get to say what I want before they say what they're offering. The hope is that if I say a high number then we will be negotiating based on that high number rather than some unknown, possibly lower one.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by cheapsteak on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @04:11PM (#12212971)
The other school of thought on this is that the first person to talk numbers has the upper hand due to anchoring power

> Just like the word suggests, you want to set a reference point around which the negotiation will revolve. Making the first offer can be to your advantage, as this offer might set the height of the negotiation bar. This anchor is the arena where the two parties will wrangle in a tug and pull negotiation scenario. Interestingly enough, many studies have shown that the first offer has a strong psychological pull, almost a magnetic lure. The resulting agreement is often strongly attracted towards the person who proposes the first offer.

http://www.negotiations.com/articles/price-negotiation/

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by erdevs on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @04:26PM (#12213099)
This works iff you shoot very high/low and if it's a very fungible range of possible outcomes. In something that is fairly well-bounded like job compensation (or most residential real estate transactions, as another example) it's usually better to let the counterparty turn the first card.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by cheapsteak on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @04:47PM (#12213269)
That's a sensible rationale as well, but if you are already familiar with the bounds of compensation, may it not be preferable to throw out a number that's slightly higher than the upper bounds of that yourself?

Since employers know the bounds as well, letting them name the first price would seem likely to result in a number that's near the mid range and not take into consideration you as an individual (skills & personality), it would be irresponsible for them not to try to mid-ball you even if they really like you, no?

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by erdevs on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @05:32PM (#12213586)
Yours is a good thought too. Here is my perspective/experience:

Scenario 1: You start at the high end of the range or just a bit above it, I think you risk the employer coming in low as a counterplay, expecting to meet in the middle. Now, it's up to you whether you do actually meet in the middle, or hold firm and move them way up, or just end the negotiation entirely. But I think this opens up their strong counterplay and establishes their ability to take the reasonable-seeming ground that it's fair to meet in the middle (even if it isn't).

Scenario 2: They throw out the first price. Scenario 2a: They throw out the first price, and it's low for the range. Now you can counterplay by going high. You also can take the strong moral high ground here by showing comp data and basically saying that it seems like they're not being fair or don't value your experience and skills correctly, which is a concern to you. Often, this will be enough to get them to offer a higher price, and you can then spring from there to continue negotiations from this higher spot. Whether they offer a higher price or not, you can start high and employ meet-in-the-middle even from the low starting point. So, Scenario 2a is no worse than Scenario 1, and has some chance of being better.

Scenario 2b: They throw out the first price, and it's mid- or high for the range. Hey! Free money! Now you can safely shoot higher and hopefully end up somewhere between where they started (already on the good side of the range) and where you countered. :-D So, again, Scenario 2b is at least as good as Scenario 1. Very rarely will a company demand no negotiation whatsoever (and maybe you want to tell them kiss off if they do, unless they have a very good philosophical / values-based reason for doing this, and they do it consistently with all candidates), so you're only bettering your position by opening the possibility for them to start somewhere above the low-end of the established market range.

By combining all the above logic, you don't want to go first.

In practice, I think this works a lot better for prospective employees too. :-) I personally think companies should offer first, for this reason (even though it's bad "negotiation" on the company's part... I actually don't think employing people is a zero-sum game, let alone a one-turn game... so I think you're better off trying to position them well. But of course not all employers think this way, and it seems in fact most do not.)

Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by vivekpreddy on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @09:50PM (#12222834)
I don't mind giving a range, but that results in a tricky situation that isn't always easy to handle. If you give a range of let's say $130k-$150k for a role, candidates' expectations are now set that if they get anything below $140k, that they're not as valued as a potential new hire.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by drdeadringer on Wednesday August 03, 2016 @03:02PM (#12220539)
I ask what the budget is when I'm asked what about my salary history.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by gozur88 on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @08:16PM (#12214471)
I like that much better. You do need some way to determine, early on, if expectations are so divergent there won't be a match.
Re:Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About... by jghn on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @07:22PM (#12214208)
This can be easier to say than to do, depending on the person.

I am now at a stage in my career/life where if anyone tried to force me to give me a number, I'd say no. If they pushed the issue, yes I'd walk away.

That wasn't always the case, there were times where I needed to be the one to fall into line. In those cases I universally got screwed as the company would always quite obviously base my offer on my current salary, even when they claimed otherwise.