News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The vanishing civility: The game of jerks, bozos and assh... by ghaff on Monday August 01, 2016 @05:42PM (#12206277)
I suspect the answer is something along the lines of:

The subject matter and associated demographics of some sites is such that, with appropriate moderation systems and commitment to consistently dealing with bad (or at least the worst) behavior, discussion forums can maintain a reasonable signal to noise ratio. The worst offenders usually get bored and go away after being banned enough times.

But a site that deals primarily with political topics? Even on HN, the level of discourse is far lower than with more fact-based technical topics. And even politically-oriented blogs and sites that I consider to have somewhat readable comments, are far more "raucous" than would be tolerated here.

And as for comments on controversial topics on truly mainstream sites like your local newspaper? That's pretty much a lost cause. There's so little signal to start with.

Re:The vanishing civility: The game of jerks, bozos and assh... by CM30 on Monday August 01, 2016 @07:22PM (#12206844)
Yeah, the topic point is a good one here. Some stuff (like the aforementioned politics, religion, controversial issues, anything 'illegal') tend towards lower quality discourse partly due to the demographics that use said sites.

Meanwhile, something fairly benign or less popular will tend to draw a much more civil audience.