Yes, I'm aware there are systems for MySQL to handle failure, but I'm also aware of the systems for Postgre, and Postgre's failure handling seem to be far saner and easier to recover from. Defense in depth against failure is easier in Postgre from my experience.
This would be like Elon Musk blogging about how "oh yeah, sometimes the brand new Tesla factory shuts down completely because sometimes the power goes out; but we're using really popular well known power distribution systems, so we're industry compliant, so everything is okay."
If Elon Musk blogged that, HN would go apeshit, and rightfully so.
Postgreql is trustworth and predictable and engineered and engineerable. Its like a German union automobile plant press operator sitting down on the job and crossing his arms until the broken safety switch is fixed, which will take precisely 3.25 hours and cost $X while the resulting assembly line shutdown costs 1000 x $X. But it'll be safe and nobody gonna lose an arm. Your downtime and related costs are more or less predictable. Maybe not the highest productivity plant in the division, but nice safety record.
Mysql is best effort. The safety switch on the press breaks, redlining that machine and shutting down the entire plant. Hmm if I stick my arm in that 50 ton press while its operating, that'll hurt a bit, so lets just not do that. Dude's a real tryhard, which always ends like you'd expect. Of course safety regulations were literally written in blood so at some unpredictable time in the future you'll get a $1M personal injury lawsuit for loss of an arm and a $10M OSHA fine, and the plant will be shut down for the criminal investigation for a random indeterminate amount of time plus the interval required to remove arm from press. Your downtime and costs are completely unpredictable, but probably mostly over a very long term for many people on average lower than postgresql. The plant will have a higher productivity metric result, and also a worse safety record.
However there is an important point that philosophy doesn't matter when times are good. Its only when the tool is misused or there's a malfunction that the underlying philosophy even shows up.
It doesn't matter which system you use when you try to store Aug 1 2016 into a date column, but (at least in the old days) it was very interesting trying to store February 30th into the databases. Insert anyway with a warning? Round up, down, or stick in a null? Normalize it to being March 2nd ish? Insert fails completely with an error? This has varies with time and configuration but in a "general sweep of history" manner you can guess correctly most of the time what each DB does.
Also there's nothing wrong in any way with a critical system that drops into philosophical best effort mode during a crisis rather than paralytic halt mode. Well, there's nothing wrong with it as long as the system was engineered with that in mind and neither the dev nor ops people are surprised by that behavior. Sometimes that is the right thing to do.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bNeZYVIfskc&t=26m54s
https://surge.omniti.com/2015/images/presentations/MattRanne... (Slides 39-63)
I'd like to have a source on that, would help shutdown a lot of MySQL discussions if true.
A typical takedown would be the likes of: http://grimoire.ca/mysql/choose-something-else (which also touches storage engine configuration things that are easier to defend against by an experienced organization). Unfortunately this sort of takedown solves very few discussions.
There are also tons of hidden gotchas that exist in, for example, the query planner. It can be extremely fickle and suddenly switch from a performant query plan to a terrible one that creates unindexed temporary tables and sorts them or joins against them. Or just ignores relevant indexes in the tables whatsoever.
Everything hums along fine until a random INSERT or UPDATE causes the query plan to change, bringing down your entire site. To be fair, such a problem can happen in any DBMS but I've never experienced it with Postgres to the extent that I have with MySQL.
Anyone with a huge production database running under load is going to have ways of mitigating these problems. Tumblr manages with MySQL, they open-sourced some of their tools like JetPants (https://github.com/tumblr/jetpants) to help build huge datasets.
So maybe Uber made a call and said "we can deal with intermittent corruption problems, we can recover from those, so long as the performance is better because a reputation for being slow is something we can't recover from". Life is all about trade-offs.
Regardless, MySQL by default silently eats data in common situations (truncation of VARCHAR) and returns flat-out incorrect results due to PHP-style "helpful" coercions (SELECT 0 == "banana"). It implements UTF-8 incorrectly, but fixing it would break existing apps, so we're forever stuck with "utf8" encoding that isn't.
There are a million more of these, and while some of them have workarounds (strict tables, utf8mb4), many of them don't (automatic coercion, boneheaded query planner, creating implicit temporary tables without indexes even when present, etc.).
A comparison of MySQL to PHP is apt, honestly. The fact that PHP is a blight doesn't mean other languages don't have their own problems. But PHP (like MySQL) is in a league of its own here.
The by design part is referring to early versions of mysql and discussions around it purposely did not care about ACID. Speed was the number one driver.
We are now investigating switching to MariaDB instead. (I'd personally love to move to Postgres, but that's not likely to happen any time soon)
This, in addition to the fact that index merging has been broken in MySQL 5.6 for more than an year now (in some cases it will cause empty resultsets to be returned), and that it is still broken on MySQL 5.7
https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.7/en/constraint-invalid-d...
https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.7/en/sql-mode.html
"The default SQL mode in MySQL 5.7 includes these modes: ONLY_FULL_GROUP_BY, STRICT_TRANS_TABLES, NO_ZERO_IN_DATE, NO_ZERO_DATE, ERROR_FOR_DIVISION_BY_ZERO, NO_AUTO_CREATE_USER, and NO_ENGINE_SUBSTITUTION."