News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by formula1 on Saturday July 30, 2016 @05:54PM (#12194834)
This really hit home for me though I don't particularly care for the retelling of history as if it was a movie. I understand the need to give perspective in order to understand the effect that Europe had on Native Americans both in north and south america. I always relate it to an invasive species that out matches the an ecosystem and doesnt curb its hunger because there is no reason to.

I find it particularly poetic how the Chief said with pride "We were the first Christian tribe". Christianity originating from the middle east with the new testimate being under European rule. Has been used countless times in europe to excuse genocide and invasion. Was brought by europeans under a guise of peace mission whom eventually went on to completely ravage two continents. Christianity even today is used to excuse persecution and oppress. Yet despite all of this, knowing it is not native gods and being on the brink of extinction and erasure from memory. He takes pride in the lasting faith in the tribe. And imagining him say those words I think of dedication and love.

Im sensitive about this because I feel like I would be consudered a necessary sacrifice or even entertaining to dominate/exploit. This particular board tends to attract alpha mentalities in the startup industry So Im curious on your thoughts

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by einhverfr on Sunday July 31, 2016 @04:25AM (#12196165)
Christianity, like Islam, and Secular Humanism is fundamentally internationalist, holding itself to be the universal ideal of correctness. Christianity and Islam both came out of, effectively the Roman Empire (in fact both the Mosque and Cathedral were built based on the plans of the same classes of Roman buildings). Secular Humanism is effectively a reinterpretation of Calvinism along atheistic lines.

As far as I can see, however, Orthodox Christianity didn't have the same history in this regard as Western Christianity did. Part of this was that the Eastern Empire lasted a lot longer, and part was that the spread occurred to Kiev and Novogorod under very different circumstances than it did to Denmark or the Franks. But in the West, the promise offered was that the Church (Roman) would help kings solidify power in return for conversion. It was from that promise that eventually the kings secured their independence by means of the reformation. And secular humanism is effectively an effort to banish competition to the state from the public square in this regard so it too is a further development of the same mistake.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by ittekimasu on Sunday July 31, 2016 @08:03AM (#12196586)
That is a very astute observation. Those of us who've seen secular humanist tenets of "rights", being cynically used for all sorts of geopolitical ends, will realize how easy it is to excite folk with such talking points.

People don't realize the dangers of such universalist notions.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by einhverfr on Sunday July 31, 2016 @10:05AM (#12197005)
And of course there is no cross-cultural empistemology that allows us to know which rights are universal, so they always become an excuse to power.
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by ittekimasu on Sunday July 31, 2016 @10:04PM (#12199850)
Indeed. Worse yet, those alien to this sphere, are not even aware of this lack of understanding - which is probably why it is so destructive, culturally, for colonized peoples.

I would've hoped those in "social sciences" would work to rectify such issues, but in their new garb of post-modernism, they've yet more become the new priesthood.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by einhverfr on Sunday July 31, 2016 @11:07PM (#12199998)
Indeed. The only reason I can see the other side to this is that I have been married to a woman from a Indonesia for over a decade now. It has been a long process to understand the cultural differences. And I have enjoyed studying anthropology quite a lot.

The one thing that does save things a little bit is that Westerners are usually so out of touch that there really isn't much room for us to do much that doesn't just effectively turn into disengagement. But even that poses real problems. I do my best to help engage in dialog on both sides of very culturally bound issues in order to try to foster some room for dialog through disagreement but getting Westerners in general (and Americans in particular) to accept that an issue like abortion or same-sex marriage is dependent on culture and other cultural institutions (such as how family relates to the economic order) is virtually impossible.

That also gets to what is wrong with multiculturalism in the US, namely that it is being pushed by people who hate culture generally.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by ittekimasu on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:05AM (#12200137)
> That also gets to what is wrong with multiculturalism in the US, namely that it is being pushed by people who hate culture generally.

I couldn't agree more; this'd have been okay had US not been so powerful geopolitically, but alas. You'll probably enjoy the tapestry around L. Carroll's "The Walrus and the Carpenter" given in "God and Gold".

(http://www.cfr.org/religion/god-gold/p13990)

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by einhverfr on Monday August 01, 2016 @01:16AM (#12200326)
Looks fascinating. The abstract dovetails on Hilaire Belloc's "The Servile State" in interesting ways. Belloc argued that the key to the success of the industrial revolution in the UK was the confiscation of Catholic church lands under Henry VIII because this created destitute masses that could be exploited in the factories. So to Belloc, Protestantism as a political system was the key to understanding the economic problems of Capitalism.

Thinking about Belloc's thesis a bit more, you have a parallel to the Confiscation of the monasteries in the US, and that was the liberation of the slaves. One can think about slave-based agriculture in the Antebellum South as increasingly industrialized (and even increasingly exploitative as a result). And the civil war not only empowered corporations with large military contracts but also in its resolution provided them with destitute masses pushed into the wage labor system. As I usually say, all racial oppression in the US has been economic in both ends and means.

But in both cases, the religious landscape evolved to match the economic landscape. And the ideological landscape quickly followed. In some rural parts of the US it is still possible to have a discussion about common good, even with people one politically disagrees with. But in the cities, it is all about individualism and rights and any questioning of the in-group orthodoxy gets one labeled as "the enemy."

It took me actually living in Indonesia for a number of years to grasp the depth of difference there. And one of the things that is worth repeating often is that when third worlders speak of first world problems, they don't regard these as trivialities. Indonesians and Malaysians don't want to become like Americans and grow old alone. To those in the third world[1], they have already rejected what Americans and British hold to be (paraphrasing Thatcher) without alternative. I now count myself in the same category.

[1] using the term in the original sense, namely countries which reject both Anglo-American capitalism and Soviet/Chinese Communism. I sometimes refer to Sweden as third world for this reason also, though it is far more Capitalist than others.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by kome on Saturday August 06, 2016 @09:21AM (#12238035)
I reply to this just to say thank you! (and to save the comment for future reference)
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by humanrebar on Sunday July 31, 2016 @07:09AM (#12196454)
> Secular Humanism is effectively a reinterpretation of Calvinism along atheistic lines.

Considering that predestination is a central theme of Calvinism, I have a hard time understanding this thought. Removing God from Calvinism doesn't leave one with much at all.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by einhverfr on Sunday July 31, 2016 @09:28AM (#12196885)
Without a mechanistic view of things, predestination is impossible. So without God, Calvinism gives us a sense of the universe as a great machine.

Other cultures may see the universe as a great mountain or a great tree.....

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by humanrebar on Sunday July 31, 2016 @01:42PM (#12197908)
A mechanicistic view is only necessary if God is mostly "hands off". Alternatively, God could be regularly be tweaking things to make sure his plan happens.
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by einhverfr on Sunday July 31, 2016 @10:55PM (#12199970)
And yet Calvin himself rejected such a tweaking view regarding predestination. His argument for predestination was simply that some people are good enough and others aren't, and God knows who is good enough and who isn't.

It's also worth noting that both Thomas Hobbes and JJ Rousseau came from Calvinist circles. So I don't think it is an exaggeration to say that the Hobbes/Rousseau (and those closely influenced by them, such as those of Locke) are effectively Calvinism as applied to society and clothed in secular rhetoric.