Would also be curious to see a comparison of different rating systems, for example i'd like to see what the distribution is on a site thumbs up/down rating site like digg vs a 5 star system.
Back to the original point -- if you used a formula with a default rating of 3 it would underestimate low-frequency movies. People don't view movies at random. They try to pick things they will like, which should be reflected in the statistical model.
> Indeed, it may be more useful in a "top rated" list to display those items with the highest number of positive ratings per page view, download, or purchase, rather than positive ratings per rating. Many people who find something mediocre will not bother to rate it at all; the act of viewing or purchasing something and declining to rate it contains useful information about that item's quality.
Minor: Distributions of ratings are not usually normal about the average possible rating -- they are usually skewed to the positive end, because people are pretty good at selecting what they read or view. The solution presented will tend to skew low-frequency ratings too far toward the average. It should be easy to calculate an expected average for your site, and use this instead of 1/2 for the formula given in the post.
Major: What you really need is a missing data point: the number of readers who haven't made any rating at all. It's pretty clear if you think of two examples:
Item 1 1,000,000 views 10 positive ratings 1 negative rating
Item 2 15 views 10 positive ratings 1 negative rating
Clearly, readers feel pretty blah about Item 1. You're much better off displaying Item 2, other things being equal, but the formula doesn't distinguish the two cases.