News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GIMP 2.9.4 and our vision for the future by phkahler on Saturday July 30, 2016 @10:58AM (#12193211)
>> I realize that this is common UX jargon, but is it literally "painful" to click "File->Export" rather than "File->Save"?

One can also make that statement to the person who decided the default save format should be different from the one the user opened. IMHO most people want to save in the format they started with and if they want to change it, something other than "save" is warranted.

Re:GIMP 2.9.4 and our vision for the future by pfranz on Saturday July 30, 2016 @12:28PM (#12193599)
This isn't just a problem with Gimp. It's a problem with Photoshop and basically every discipline where there's a bunch of file formats that have varying levels of support for features.

"Open" would then more correctly called "Import" for most file formats. If you want Open and Save to work with all file formats, you'd then need to restrict the UI to operations that work with the file format you have open. Otherwise, you lose data when saving.

>> IMHO most people want to save in the format they started with and if they want to change it, something other than "save" is warranted.

Most people when they save a file expect everything to be there when they open it later. That's only possible when you save using that applications proprietary file format.

Re:GIMP 2.9.4 and our vision for the future by chickenfries on Saturday July 30, 2016 @01:18PM (#12193787)
If I open a PNG in Photoshop, crop it or resize it, it stays in PNG when I save it. This is such a common workflow that it makes me wonder if you use Photoshop.

I understand your points, but it doesn't mean that there aren't pragmatic UX choices to be made here.

Re:GIMP 2.9.4 and our vision for the future by reitanqild on Saturday July 30, 2016 @02:40PM (#12194134)
One is potentially destructive, the other is potentially annoying. I know for certain which one I would choose as the default action.
Re:GIMP 2.9.4 and our vision for the future by bobwaycott on Saturday July 30, 2016 @12:21PM (#12193574)
This. It is far too common for applications to default to saving their own .special format, despite opening another fully supported format. Save should always default to file type opened, and .special format when a new file was created. Save As is an easy and friendly enough vector for allowing saving that opened .whatever file as a .special when specifically wanted. It really is unfriendly increased mental load to open a .whatever and have to remember or figure out you must Export to retain your file type.