News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Daring Fireball: On Submarine Patents vis-à-vis H.264 and... by ubernostrum on Thursday March 25, 2010 @03:39AM (#1217935)
Laches doesn't invalidate a patent; it simply allows you to defend yourself in the particular case you raise it in.

Laches is a form of estoppel, which is geared around the basic idea that if you do something I could sue you over, and you can show that:

1. I did something which gave you a reasonable belief that I wouldn't sue you, and

2. That was the only reason you went ahead and did it, then

3. I don't get to turn around and go after you, because it was really my actions which created the situation.

In a laches defense, you show that the person suing you for patent infringement knew you were doing or were going to do something which infringed, and deliberately waited to come forward with their claims so as to do the most possible damage to you. You argue that, had you known about their claims earlier, you would have done something different, and so it was their inaction which led to the current situation.

This doesn't stop the patent holder from going after other people, so long as they do it in a timely manner; the patent is still valid and can still be enforced. It also doesn't automatically stop future claims against you; it's expected, now that you're aware of their patent, that you'll work out some licensing deal to avoid future infringement. But it can throw out their current case against you, or at least throw out the massive back damages you'd owe from infringement over the period when the patent holder didn't bother doing anything.

Re:Daring Fireball: On Submarine Patents vis-à-vis H.264 and... by guelo on Thursday March 25, 2010 @04:12AM (#1217961)
"Laches doesn't invalidate a patent"

I disagree. In Symbol Technologies Inc. v. Lemelson Medical, the courts declared Lemelson's submarine patents unenforceable under the doctrine of prosecution laches.

Re:Daring Fireball: On Submarine Patents vis-à-vis H.264 and... by ubernostrum on Thursday March 25, 2010 @05:21AM (#1218005)
The Lemelson case was a rather extreme example; normally, a laches defense only applies to a specific defendant or defendants in a specific case. With the Lemelson case, the court explicitly noted that it was doing something extraordinary, and went to some lengths to explain how that situation differed from a typical laches case.