I don't think anyone can be _the_ very best and I think that's not a reasonable or attainable goal.
We value T shaped developers, and our salary matrix values both spreading breadth (e.g. as a mobile dev if I up my skills in sysadmin or data science) or depth (which is a bit harder to do if you're already experienced) which fits into that nicely.
> I don't think anyone can be _the_ very best and I think that's not a reasonable or attainable goal.
... kinda proves my point of not needing a "five" rating.
You are confusing 2 things. The salary is (effectively) determined by the average skill rating of a person. The single skills can and do go up to AAA+++, and this raises the average and thus the salary.
While having an average of 5 is very difficult, having a super high maximum is actually meaningful. Some people are special in some area and we recognize that.
EDIT: clarified terms (see https://stackoverflow.com/company/salary/skills/web-develope... for the formulas)
I don't understand the rationality behind this. Why have (nearly) impossible to reach ratings? I mean, by this logic, the most talented people will only ever be a 4, yes? So make 4 the limit. You just came off of saying you'd never make an offer to an 80K candidate who thinks they're worth 100K[0]. Yet, you're telling your very best that they'll never be _the_ very best because basically nobody is a "five".
[0] It's what you were basically responding to.
Edit: for clarification.