News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should We Torture Suspected Terrorists? by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @12:49PM (#12174377)
> Just as in my example of a surgical intervention after a traffic accident, this is no guarantee of 100% success

No, with torture there is no scenario, given everything I've seen on the issue including from experts in interrogation, in which you can conclude that torture is more likely than other techniques which you will have the capacity to perform if you have the capacity (e.g., control of the target, access to trained interrogators) to perform torture.

Its not that torture lacks a guarantee of success, it is that there is no way to identify (and, thus, limit) torture to any set of circumstances where torture is even most likely to be the most effective approach.

And, therefore, any policy which ever chooses torture will be suboptimally effective in preventing the harms it seeks to prevent.

That's the problem with torture, even within the framework of a relatively myopic utilitarianism.

And torture gets worse from the perspective of a more holistic utilitarianism, once you consider the effects of actually performing torture on the broader society and, including on those who actually perform it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.