News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter's Fucked by raiyu on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @11:50AM (#12173800)
Every platform that is public and anonmyous runs afoul of this, this isn't just twitter. You can look at Youtube comments, reddit, pretty much any forum.

What's missing is that other platforms, like Facebook, took a very hard stance on this and forced people to signup as their real identities.

Twitter, can easily follow suit. That won't fix all of the problems, but it will go towards improving things and it won't require massive product updates and changes to the UX.

Given that their MAU growth numbers are low, and no longer the number that they want the public market to focus on, actually instating this now wouldn't even be that damaging from a reporting perspective, and if they bled out a few users that weren't really contributing it could go a long way to improving things.

Technically there is a privacy setting that twitter doesn't play up that can be used for people that want to use twitter as a consumption platform and limit the interactivity from other people.

Twitter is still fundamentally different and more open than facebook and with requesting non-anonymous users they can still keep that open platform and potentially clean up some of the outlier conversations that seem to be a focus for so many people of what's wrong with twitter.

Re:Twitter's Fucked by bmo311 on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @12:29PM (#12174200)
If you think that enforcing real names induces civility and you use Facebook as an example, your argument is wrong and self-contradictory.

Facebook is /proof/ that the Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory doesn't need anonymity. What the Internet proves about communication is that fuckwaddery (yes, this is a word, my word) is inversely proportional to interface friction. The quicker it is to spill the contents of your mind without the filtration enabled by interface difficulty, the more crap you can put out. Since 90 percent of everything is crap, [Sturgeon] even what you are thinking 90 percent of the time is crap and you're lucky if you manage to only commit the remaining 10 percent without contaminating it with the rest. Interface difficulty enforces thinking about what you commit to discussion. Which is why pen-and-ink letter writing "is an art" and the twitterverse is a cesspool - real names or not.

This is not to say that if everything went back to pen-and-paper that there would be no fuckwads. There would simply be fewer of them.

Lastly, I never used my real name on Facebook or other social media. Why should I give up what I have every right to do in real life just because it's electronic? People don't care whether I'm using my real name or alias as long as they know who they're talking to.

BMO's Revised Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory

(Normal person + communication medium) / interface friction = fuckwad

And when friction=0, you have a black hole of fuckwaddery. You usually get this when you use alcohol as a lubricant.

Re:Twitter's Fucked by CM30 on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @01:46PM (#12174956)
I'd say fuckwaddery or whatever is more proportional to the distance between the user and the person they're communicating with. If someone lives in the same town, you'll be a lot more hesitant to insult the hell out of them than if they live on another continent.

That might be why Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, etc are so screwed up. Because the userbase knows that there's a very slim chance they'll ever meet the person they're attacking online. That there's a slim chance there'll ever be any genuine consequences for their actions.

Of course, making it easier and more convenient like on the sites (or limiting people to only 140 characters) definitely makes it easier to be a douche. But you're not going to send a threatening SMS message to someone sitting next to you.

Re:Twitter's Fucked by intended on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:13PM (#12175227)
Bullies operate on people who are in the same school as them, it has nothing to do with distance.
Re:Twitter's Fucked by sievebrain on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @12:19PM (#12174104)
HN is public and anonymous and mostly manages to not suffer this problem, due to the heavy manual labour of the moderators and a whole lot of selection bias in its userbase.

To a slightly lesser extent, Slashdot has also licked that problem: for any story that attracts enough comments (more than 300) the top rated ones are often pretty good and the worthless ones start auto-collapsed. Even though Slashdot gets a lot of jip these days, some of it deserved, I've still spent many enjoyable hours reading some of the top rated comments there. Especially nice is the fact that upvotes must have an adjective attached, which gently nudges users into certain kinds of behaviour. For instance it's the only site I've encountered where people often post extremely funny comments despite the serious topics. The moderation system there encourages that sort of behaviour.

Re:Twitter's Fucked by xseven on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @12:55PM (#12174436)
HN is not as mainstream as Twitter or Reddit, so I don't think we can really compare it that way
Re:Twitter's Fucked by dabockster on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @01:45PM (#12174944)
I wouldn't necessarily consider Reddit mainstream either. Sure, it has a lot of users. But I don't hear people on the streets telling each other to look at their subreddits.
Re:Twitter's Fucked by gedrap on Friday July 29, 2016 @08:08AM (#12186286)
If we can trust in Alexa, reddit is #26 globally and #9 in the US. Even with some error margin, that's damn mainstream.
Re:Twitter's Fucked by heed on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @12:26PM (#12174175)
Also Metacritic has managed to keep foul comments under control.
Re:Twitter's Fucked by glomek on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @12:47PM (#12174366)
> Every platform that is public and anonmyous runs afoul of this, this isn't just twitter. You can look at Youtube comments, reddit, pretty much any forum.

We had ways of dealing with this on Usenet back in the day. 1) Thick skin, and 2) killfiles. Generally, killfiles weren't for people with whom you disagreed (though they could be, if you wanted), they were for people who were assholes.