Past performance is no guarantee of future performance.
You're also ignoring the carrying costs of a house.
Of course there are monthly payments and maintenance too, but you'd have to live somewhere even if you didn't own a house. To account for those properly in calculating the real return, you really should diff them against the rent on an equivalent property. And don't forget the interest tax deduction.
Finally there is the wonderful fact that capital gains on your primary residence can be kept tax-free up to $250,000 ($500,000 if you're married).
Indeed, taxes and insurance can dominate the mortgage.
At that point, if you need to sell, you've lost your down payment, as in WA at least, it costs approx 9.3% to sell a house (unless you're in an insanely sellers market, which you're not if you're down).
https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=marginnew&...
The best model for that is to be a bank with the 3/6/3 model.
Borrow at 3%, lend at 6%, on the golf course by 3 PM.
Now doing something similar with stocks.... that's kind of Warren Buffett's model. He uses insurance companies like Berkshire and Aflac to create cash flows to buy stocks.
I guess you could use options to do something similar.
Is there any way to do something similar with stocks, without paying an insane amount of money in interest rates or fees?
Edit: I know returns aren't guaranteed, I'm referring to expected returns. I'm perfectly willing to take on risk, in order to make positive-EV bets. I tossed out the 5-7% number as a very rough approximation - assuming that you buy a house with a buy-rent ratio of < 20, in which case the returns that you make by not having to pay rent, will be 5% or more.