News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Book Piracy as Peer Preservation by softawre on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @12:07PM (#12166608)
> Drug users are punished with posession

That's a counter-example. Drug punishments aren't related to this at all, but we do charge people for possession AND we charge people for distribution.

Re:Book Piracy as Peer Preservation by deepnet on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @12:31PM (#12166789)
You would be right if there was a law 'watching infringing material', equivalent to 'receiving stolen goods' - but there is no such law.

I have received a lot of emotive disagreement and conflation of terms but where is the statute or precedent that says downloading is illegal ?

There is none. Sadly or happily depending on ones position.

Yet I don't understand all this disagreement with the facts.

Please if you believe I am wrong it would be quite easy to substantiate the argument by a citation of statute or precedent.

I have looked into this matter quite extensively and there is no such legal prohibition.