News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GoDaddy pulls out of China too by bad_user on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @03:31PM (#1216639)
> In some ways though I do think it is a well intentioned idea

Yeah, well ... the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

They already have enough to identify you, unless you've given a false name / address. In which case they would only have to track the financial transaction ... and impose a rule that domains with untraceable owners should instantly be terminated (and I think this already applies to all tlds).

What in the world do they need a picture for?

I guess it's for fast reaction times, to identify more efficiently when they send the police at your door. Or for increased levels of paranoia amongst the population, keeping you honest and all that.

Re:GoDaddy pulls out of China too by jeffmould on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @04:01PM (#1216711)
Oh I agree the photo is excessive. Never said the whole idea was great, just that the theory of requiring business registration verification or name verification is most likely well intentioned.

What makes the whole thing skeptical and scary is that it is the government asking for this and not a specific registrar's policy.

Re:GoDaddy pulls out of China too by bad_user on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @05:24PM (#1216929)
> the theory of requiring business registration verification or name verification is most likely well intentioned.

But what good will that do?

Surely having a verifiable online ID might be useful in collaborating with other people that might need some assurance you're a real person that's accountable for his behavior.

But for domains, the only requirement should be as it is now ... that you must give accurate contact information. And asking for an address is too much for me anyway ... since if you're not careful about protecting it, you can become a target for maniacs (I'm still pretty pissed off about what happened to Kathy Sierra, which had the best blog I've ever read).

Either way, you won't get rid of spammers, fraudsters or jerkiness.