Re:Google X: Waiting for a Moonshot
by iainmerrick on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @11:16AM
(#12166215)
You're right, I suppose it's a continuum -- everything is incremental to some degree or other.
The Manhattan project is probably the best example, because there was nothing to build on except "science strongly suggests we could make a bomb out of this; we have no idea yet how to solve the practical issues, or even what all the practical issues are." It was partly incremental in that a much smaller nuclear bomb would still have been useful, but there was definitely a big risk that it just wouldn't work at all.
The Manhattan project is probably the best example, because there was nothing to build on except "science strongly suggests we could make a bomb out of this; we have no idea yet how to solve the practical issues, or even what all the practical issues are." It was partly incremental in that a much smaller nuclear bomb would still have been useful, but there was definitely a big risk that it just wouldn't work at all.