News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by Mithaldu on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @02:57AM (#12163798)
In a sane system the health insurance costs scale with wages.

Do the US ones not do that?

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by aplummer on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @03:35AM (#12163915)
In a sane system healthcare is provided to everyone free and has nothing to do with employment status ;)
Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by zaroth on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @09:25AM (#12165401)
There's no such thing. It's just deluding yourself and a bit dishonest to say "free" in this context, please try to say what you mean.

Is it actually, 'In a sane system healthcare is billed to everyone as a percentage tax on their income capped at some dollar amount'. Or perhaps you think it should be an uncapped percentage of income? I expect there is no country on Earth where the cost of healthcare literally has nothing to do with employment status, in-so-much as single-payer healthcare is always funded at least partially by income taxes.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by soundwave106 on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @10:17AM (#12165749)
One advantage most other countries have, with the government being the plan manager, is that the pool of taxes they can utilize for funding is larger. Income taxes partially fund health care, yes, but so does VAT.

But at any rate, if you ignore the "free" point of the original poster, that post was quite correct. America leans heavily on corporations to perform the management of health care, and I don't see that as particularly "sane" to be honest. To me, such is an unnecessary competitive advantage to large corporations that can better manage the bureaucracy and expense. Small business owners often cannot afford the time and expense to offer this (understandably, to be honest). Consequently, employees that are self-employed or working for small companies may have to forgo health insurance.

It is very possible that this leads to some talented employees resisting leaving a corporation purely for health insurance reasons, a phenomenon called "job lock" (https://www.jstor.org/stable/2118427?seq=1#page_scan_tab_con...).

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by zaroth on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @08:18AM (#12172145)
At least when corporations search for a health plan, they are intensely competitive in finding the best plan for the price. Every year when their policies renew is another round of searching, comparing, and analyzing the various options in their local market. Health insurance has got to be the most expensive benefit a company offers by far, and I know even at a small startup we spend a lot of time finding the best plan for the money for our group.

Compare that to the US government, which isn't even legally allowed to negotiate on drug costs, and look where that has brought us [1,2]. So you could argue companies "waste" an enormous amount of resources having to procure health insurance for their employees year after year, but it also at least helps establish at least some competition in the market, which puts at least some pressure on prices. Companies health insurance budgets are not unlimited (unlike the Fed's) so we don't see quite the same run-away pricing as you do when the purchaser is literally printing the money to pay for it.

Obama's famous "you can keep your Doctor" lie is very telling. Different companies will elect for very different levels of coverage. The law requires that whatever level of coverage you chose to offer your employees is offered consistently from management down to your cheapest full-time employee, which is a really smart policy. Large corporations have better negotiating power in almost all respects of their operations, supply chain, and yes, employee benefits. We wouldn't imagine trying to 'level the playing field' in any other aspect of the operation of a company, so I don't think that's a compelling argument for single-payer health insurance?

When small businesses chose to forgo even offering health insurance (which is that even legal now?) that is actually a competitive advantage for them; they avoid a huge operating cost, and implicitly are selecting for the type of worker they are looking for -- single, young, and healthy.

[1] - https://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data-and-Systems/Sta...

[2] - http://www.nola.com/politics/index.ssf/2016/07/medicare_pric...

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by soundwave106 on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @10:37AM (#12173113)
The advantage of a "single payer" system would be to bring the benefits of large corporation negotiating power down to everyone.

If there was no competition at all, I'm sure that there is some potential for rising costs. But a lot of "single payer" systems actually do offer a fair bit of wiggle room for private market competition. The mess that is the state of the United States government health care really isn't a compelling argument here against single payer (the statistics for most of the rest of the world's health care systems, which are more integrated, kind of show this). I would expect that any "Medicaid / Medicare for all" system emerge in the United States would be two-tiered, like is the case in several other countries.

To be honest, I would almost describe the situation in America as oligopoly-like in many cases (in insurance and hospital networks in particular) depending on where you are, and that would mute the effect of any corporate competition.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by aplummer on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @10:19PM (#12177923)
You've made a false assumption that "intense competition" (italicised for emphasis!) always makes things cheaper. It doesn't apply with health insurance, which is why health costs are so much higher in the U.S than anywhere else. [1]

Fact: the system of private health insurance in the U.S makes it more expensive for everyone. Source: every other western country paying far less. It is possible for the free market to fail when the thing people are buying is something they would pay any amount of money for.

[1]http://gamapserver.who.int/gho/interactive_charts/health_fin...

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by aplummer on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @10:12PM (#12177905)
Obviously I am talking about free like "education", not free as in "no human input" It's a bit "dishonest" to take ridiculous literal meaning of the word to misrepresent what's clearly my point.

To explain fully, I am advocating the system where a person who earns $0 per day can enter and leave a hospital treated for free. They don't work, don't contribute to society, but as a unit everyone just agrees to look after their basic health as a minimum. As well people with money can do the same without even a thought about what their health insurance does / doesn't cover or when it kicks in, they just pitch up to the hospital.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by Mithaldu on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @03:51AM (#12163980)
That is of course implicit. No wages, no costs.

The funding for health care still needs to come from somewhere, this optimally being a tax on income.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by aplummer on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @10:23PM (#12177939)
Yeah I got straw-manned pretty hard (and took the bait), like I was advocating a fully volunteer health network or money on trees situation...
Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by maerF0x0 on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @03:34AM (#12163912)
Why would that be a sane system? IMO a sane system is one where the paid cost scales with the real costs of the health care, no?

Ones health care costs arent going to be cut in half if hours are cut in half. Still need just as many annual checkups, may still have the same diabetes etc.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @05:31AM (#12164387)
It is a sane system because everyone is paying into it, and you can do things on a larger scale to help more people. With health care being disconnected from the job, it doesn't tie people to an employer they hate and changing jobs is less of a risk. There are pluses and minuses, of course.

They still should have checkups, but not everyone needs them annually. Still might have diabetes, but with less stress and actually having time to cook proper meals, the diabetes might be better controlled and have cost savings in the long term (fewer complications) - and possibly short term if they have type 2 and go from insulin to pills. Sweden has been testing out 6 hour days - with nurses, they find overall absenteeism has dropped and folks are happier. Large scale, this would probably mean that folks are sick less often. Might not be cut by 25%, but improvement is still improvement.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by Mithaldu on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @03:53AM (#12163988)
No, health care is implicitly a system of shared costs to benefit all of society by limiting the amount of ill people present as much as possible, thus increasing the health of everyone else by reducing contacts with ill people. In such a system, costs are of course taken on by every single participant according to their means.

Read up on german health insurance for example.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by waqf on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @04:27AM (#12164125)
I agree that that is a sane system, but it's not correct to call the payment an "insurance cost" if it is calculated according to means, not according to expected future treatment costs.

That's what was causing the confusion and dissent.

(Also … don't ask what US health insurance costs are based on. It's too horrible to contemplate. They're based on, among other things, your employer's negotiating power vis-à-vis the health insurance industry.)

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by Mithaldu on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @04:31AM (#12164146)
Fair enough. I spoke a little simply.
Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by usrusr on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @04:30AM (#12164138)
Forgive my sarcasm:

> Read up on german health insurance for example.

Which one, the one where middle income employees pay healthcare for all the poor and incapable, or the one where the wealthy and some happy civil servants don't?

The American system is terrible, but I really don't think that we are qualified to point fingers.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by douche on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @07:15AM (#12164766)
>the one where middle income employees pay healthcare for all the poor and incapable

That about sums up the US system... I don't particularly like the idea of the federal government getting their grubby fingers into more than they are constitutionally mandated to, but a single-payer system could cut out the byzantine insurance coding and billing bureaucracy that causes medical costs to be completely arbitrary and opaque.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by Mithaldu on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @04:33AM (#12164156)
You failed to formulate a coherent disagreement. Please address the actual points of my post and speak clearly.
Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by clarkmoody on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @09:24AM (#12165393)
> In a sane system ... US

No. Almost nothing about the US healthcare system is sane, by any interpretation of the word.

Re:Ask HN: Why don't companies hire programmers for fewer ho... by subhobroto on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @04:33PM (#12168548)
In a sane system the health insurance pays for only catastrophic scenarios and has nothign to do with employment.

Providers post prices publicly and compete on said prices while maintaining customer satisfaction.

The US does not do that.

We have 1000s of reviews for restaurants and how the server behaved but no site where you can type a zip code and a procedure and get a list of providers and their prices and reviews.