Re:Goodbye, Object Oriented Programming
by klibertp on Monday July 25, 2016 @05:03AM
(#12157365)
> Except that there is a real advantage to using pure functional programming
That's only true for certain values of "real". In real "real" terms, the advantage is purely virtual - even very simple programs require hundreds of pages of proof. In effect, formal proofs are almost never done in real reality and the "advantage" remains purely virtual.
> what's new about it (privileging the first argument of each procedure
Multimethods, CLOS, Dylan?
> inheritance
Don't use it if you don't like it that much...
> lots of hidden mutable state
It's not hidden, it's encapsulated. Do you know Smalltalk? If not, you should try learning it; I liked Pharo very much. Look at Morphic, work with it for a while and you'll see the difference. You can also try devising purely functional equivalent of Morphic while you're at it (good luck!).
That's only true for certain values of "real". In real "real" terms, the advantage is purely virtual - even very simple programs require hundreds of pages of proof. In effect, formal proofs are almost never done in real reality and the "advantage" remains purely virtual.
> what's new about it (privileging the first argument of each procedure
Multimethods, CLOS, Dylan?
> inheritance
Don't use it if you don't like it that much...
> lots of hidden mutable state
It's not hidden, it's encapsulated. Do you know Smalltalk? If not, you should try learning it; I liked Pharo very much. Look at Morphic, work with it for a while and you'll see the difference. You can also try devising purely functional equivalent of Morphic while you're at it (good luck!).