News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google X: Waiting for a Moonshot by nostrademons on Monday July 25, 2016 @01:43AM (#12156717)
GMail and Google Maps were also both ruthlessly incremental. They seemed like big improvements over what had come before because they had incubated inside the Googleplex for a couple years before they were released, and because the competition hadn't improved in nearly a decade.

It's more that Search was a non-incremental leap forwards, and that Google was basically the only company of the dot-com era that had attempted an ambitious technological goal and succeeded. Google Search really was fundamentally different from previous technologies; its main rival Alta Vista, for example, ran on a single box and used very standard text-ranking techniques, while Google thought very much out-of-the-box in terms of ranking, scale, and architecture.

Google X is very much a Larry & Sergey project, and Larry (while Eric was CEO) was often very critical of how incremental employee projects were and how they weren't taking enough risks on fundamentally different approaches.

Re:Google X: Waiting for a Moonshot by iainmerrick on Monday July 25, 2016 @02:18AM (#12156815)
Amazon is a much better example of a moonshot than Google search. The key idea is easy to state: an easy-to-use online store for almost anything, with fast and cheap delivery. But how on earth do you make that work in practice? You need a ton of business deals with various manufacturers and brands, you need warehouses everywhere, you need a massive delivery network... the investment required is just staggering. And indeed, for many years they were criticised for not making a profit, but the investment is clearly paying off.
Re:Google X: Waiting for a Moonshot by qihqi on Monday July 25, 2016 @11:14AM (#12159220)
At the beginning, Jeff have only thought of an online book company, instead becoming the 'Everything Store'. This legacy still exists as ASIN (Amazon Stock Indentification Number) is extended on ISBN to work on legacy systems.
Re:Google X: Waiting for a Moonshot by iainmerrick on Monday July 25, 2016 @01:55AM (#12156751)
Google search used a couple of clever innovations -- the PageRank algorithm, and scaling via lots of small computers. But apart from that, isn't it almost the definition of incremental? You don't need a massive investment to make it work, just a couple of grad students with 10 PCs to make a proof of concept, then 100 PCs to make it better, then 500...

Thinking about it, Google's key business trick has never been moonshots, it's been "throwing things against the wall to see what sticks". It's a wide approach (invest speculatively in lots of different ideas) rather than a deep one (bet heavily on a really long shot).

Re:Google X: Waiting for a Moonshot by visarga on Monday July 25, 2016 @02:26AM (#12156835)
They practically operate their own business incubator.