News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by byuu on Sunday July 24, 2016 @05:29PM (#12155003)
That really had to be the dumbest moves in computing history.

"What does the #2 CPU maker need to become #1? The #2 GPU maker, obviously!"

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by yulaow on Sunday July 24, 2016 @05:46PM (#12155063)
Well to defend them they needed a solution to fight the incoming intel cpu with integrated gpu. They needed ATI portfolio and knowledges.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by monocasa on Sunday July 24, 2016 @06:29PM (#12155219)
Yeah, exactly. If they didn't have their APUs, they wouldn't have hardly anything anymore.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by byuu on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:03PM (#12155627)
The integrated GPU really didn't need that kind of power, though. Anyone playing more than solitaire is going to get a discrete GPU anyway. They could have snapped up a smaller chipset maker for a tenth of the price.

Instead they entered both the integrated and discrete GPU markets, when they were already a market underdog that already struggled in the CPU market. They paid way too much for ATI, and then spread themselves way too thin.

I'm not just pointing out the error in hindsight, I was a critic of this deal back when it was first announced as well.

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by pcwalton on Monday July 25, 2016 @02:47AM (#12156911)
> Anyone playing more than solitaire is going to get a discrete GPU anyway

That's not true. The PC enthusiast market is a small segment of the overall PC market, and that's not even counting mobiles. Lots of people play non-graphically-intensive games.

More importantly, GPUs are hugely important for things that aren't games. Honestly, the fact that video needs hardware acceleration (which is part of the media/GPU block) means that there's a reasonable argument that games aren't even the most important practical function of a GPU.

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by gcp on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:29AM (#12158509)
Current Intel iGPU, and especially AMD APUs are powerful enough to play all the most popular esports games, despite them being quite a bit more demanding than solitaire.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by dogma1138 on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:01PM (#12155620)
Well NVIDIA wanted to spin off into the CPU market also, they sorta did with them building ARM based SOC's with NVIDIA GPU's. There were also rumors of them licensing x86 from Intel.

Oddly enough NVIDIA back in the day made what arguable was the best chipset for AMD CPU's - NVIDIA nForce.

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by monocasa on Monday July 25, 2016 @01:42PM (#12160225)
The nForce wasn't really their IP though; it was AMDs. The original Xbox was in prototype phase and consisted of an AMD CPU and AMD chipset with some Nvidia IP for the GPU. Intel comes along and offers a PIII variant for really cheap. Part of the deal that Intel struck was that there can't be any AMD logos on the box, but they don't haven enough time to change out the chipset whoelsale, only to switch out the FSB. So Microsoft pays AMD to licence their 7XX chipset to Nvidia, so now it's all IP properly owned by Nvidia. For whatever reason, there were no restrictions on Nvidia only being able to use this for the Xbox, so they continued updating and releasing that genetic line of IP as nForce.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by gcp on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:31AM (#12158518)
There's also some belief Project Denver was supposed to be an x86 core and could still be turned into one.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by bakgwailo on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:13PM (#12155660)
NVIDIA could never have gotten an x86 license, as they would have required a ton of licensing from AMD, too. Plus it would violate the cross licensing agreement between Intel, AMD, and VIA.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by dogma1138 on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:46PM (#12155777)
NVIDIA used to make an X86 processor long time ago an embedded 386SX. Around 2010 they were snooping around including trying to build an X86 emulator that would run on their HPC parts which started a small turf war with Intel/AMD which was settled. http://www.anandtech.com/show/4122/intel-settles-with-nvidia...
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by devonkim on Sunday July 24, 2016 @07:42PM (#12155545)
The idea was that a CPU + GPU company would be a lot stronger than themselves trying to defend against their respective #1 competitors. Instead, both the CPU and GPU market leaders got stronger and leveraged their massive capital to turn the #2 into a very, very distant #2.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by Macha on Sunday July 24, 2016 @07:46PM (#12155565)
It also changed the decision process from "Pick 1 of Intel and AMD, plus pick 1 of nVidia and ATI" to "Pick Intel/nVidia or AMD/AMD" for companies like Dell/HP etc. so AMD and ATI's weaknesses compounded each other from then on.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by dogma1138 on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:04PM (#12155632)
Not sure, having the GPU division allowed them to bid for the Xbox and PS contracts.

Having an APU allows them to play in the low end market which was dominated by Intel with their IGP, the vast majority of laptops do not come with a discrete GPU which meant that AMD could not compete with Intel at all prior to their acquisition of ATI unless they would develop their own GPU or license it from some one (they had plans of licensing PowerVR at some point IIRC).

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by Osiris on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:26PM (#12155710)
Exactly, there's a reason that Xbox and PlayStation are both using AMD chips. What those systems needed was a lot more GPU power than CPU power, so AMD was well positioned to do that.

It's not a massive money maker for them, but I think that it positioned them well to push open standards like FreeSync, and Mantle/Vulcan. AMD is also fighting back by trying to develop open standards, knowing that proprietary ones wouldn't ever get any traction.

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by gcp on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:32AM (#12158523)
>knowing that proprietary ones wouldn't ever get any traction.

Not unless AMD had a dominant market position. CUDA dominating the ecosystem right now is a major PITA, and so is the insistence on GSync over FreeSync.

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by syshum on Monday July 25, 2016 @05:39AM (#12157492)
AMD had about as much of a Chance at breaking in the to Intel Dominated OEM market as Linux had to become the default operating systems on all Consumers PC's

MS and Intel both put EXTREME pressure and incentives on OEM (and both were accused of Anti-Trust Violations) to keep their defacto monopolies

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by macspoofing on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:22PM (#12155694)
You think Dell or HP would ever have sidelined Intel? AMD was going to get shafted, no matter what.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by twblalock on Monday July 25, 2016 @03:43AM (#12157087)
Dell and HP would have sidelined Intel in a heartbeat if they could have made more money by switching to AMD.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by devonkim on Monday July 25, 2016 @09:21AM (#12158467)
The Intel advertising campaign kept their branding quite strong in the consumer market and there'd have been an uphill battle to get consumers onto the AMD train for even Dell and other OEMs. With consoles, the branding isn't the CPUs but the console maker's and the audience generally doesn't include grandma & grandpa that only ever watch TV commercials and see an occasional newspaper advertisement when it comes to technology.

On the business technology side it'd be even harder due to thermal characteristics that have been demanded for over a decade now and Intel destroys AMD there without question.

Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by devonkim on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:08PM (#12155645)
The market was already dividing out that way honestly, and if you are going to be a low-margin, higher-volume player, you should try to work on economy of scale as part of your market differentiation factors.
Re:Yahoo sold to US telecoms giant Verizon by macspoofing on Sunday July 24, 2016 @08:19PM (#12155684)
Why not? I still don't see why it was an inherently bad idea. There's a lot of overlap in the CPU and GPU business.

What happened was that Intel got its game back and then both, Intel and AMD, missed the mobile train. On the ATI side, they were outcompeted by Nvidia. Bad luck, and bad strategy.