News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Majority Illusion in Social Networks by argonaut on Saturday July 23, 2016 @09:12PM (#12151750)
For any given arxiv article, I'd wager 98% of people on HN are unqualified to critically review the article. They're not aware of prior work that might contradict the article. They're not aware of the limitations of prior work that the article cites. They've never tried the experimental or theoretical methods the article uses, and so on. Yet these are the people upvoting and commenting on implications.
Re:The Majority Illusion in Social Networks by sievebrain on Sunday July 24, 2016 @11:38AM (#12153569)
98% sounds like a made up stat, so if you grant me the same privilege then let's say HN has 1 million readers. So 2% of that would be 20,000 people qualified to judge the article, which is plenty of people.
Re:The Majority Illusion in Social Networks by argonaut on Monday July 25, 2016 @04:34AM (#12157259)
1) HN has 300k daily uniques (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9219581). Of those readers, nearly all do not comment (we don't have 300k comments, do we?). Of those commentors, only a fraction comment on a given article.

2) Of those commenters, most are not actual researchers, who are, IMO, much, much busier with real work (you know... research) than your average HN commenter.

Re:The Majority Illusion in Social Networks by sievebrain on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @04:16AM (#12164087)
Of course most don't comment, but commenting is not required for a paper to be peer reviewed, only reviewing it is. If someone were to see the paper here, and review it, and find an error, presumably they would contact the author.

300k * 0.02 = 6000 people who may be qualified. How many people are typically asked to peer review a paper? A handful? The odds are still good.

Re:The Majority Illusion in Social Networks by argonaut on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @07:44PM (#12169577)
The original poster was talking about what would be better for the HN community. The HN community is a discussion forum, not a system of people privately emailing.