News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Category Theory for the Sciences by paulpauper on Saturday July 23, 2016 @02:22PM (#12150441)
I know I'm probably going to keep getting down-voted ,but if it's merely abstract and not complicated ,why is category theory considered a difficult course? They don't teach it in undergrad. Is it because it is poorly taught, or students don't like abstractions, or students are ill-prepared, etc. The question I'm digging at is what makes something hard to understand versus easy
Re:Category Theory for the Sciences by yodsanklai on Saturday July 23, 2016 @03:03PM (#12150591)
Maybe because category theory makes sense only after you have sufficient math background? Just like it's easier to make sense of the definition of algebraic structures when you're already familiar with enough of their instances.

An other reason, maybe category theory isn't that useful? I'm just speculating here as I have only basic knowledge of category theory, maybe someone else can enlighten us! While all the maths taught at undergraduate level are extremely useful and pervasive in all areas of science, I'm still unsure about category theory. It's certainly nice and elegant as it allows us to reframe different theories and definitions in a same context, but is it useful for an engineer or an applied mathematician?

Re:Category Theory for the Sciences by Smaug123 on Saturday July 23, 2016 @03:15PM (#12150638)
Category theory is very useful for certain branches of pure mathematics (and it instils a very useful mindset in the mathematician), but much less so for applied mathematics.

Also you're quite right that category theory only really starts to make sense when you have a big stock of examples, like "group theory" and "poset theory" and "topology" and "set theory". Once you've got those examples, you can detect these common threads between them and call them "category theory".

Re:Category Theory for the Sciences by Koshkin on Saturday July 23, 2016 @04:35PM (#12150909)
On the other hand, at least some of the ideas from the category theory have already made their way into the _practice_ of programming. I am talking about the notion of a monad. It has already become an important tool in functional programming; but even in mostly-imperative programming languages such as C# one can discern important patterns as instances of this concept. Contrary to the common perception, it is not hard to understand. Two basic examples: the optional (a.k.a. nullable) type construct is an example of a monad (called 'Maybe' monad in Haskell); a generic list construct is another one. I think it is enlightening to be able to see a common pattern behind these, seemingly different, things. And this is exactly where the power and the usefulness of the category theory lies - in mathematics or elsewhere.
Re:Category Theory for the Sciences by dllthomas on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @01:58PM (#12175110)
> the optional (a.k.a. nullable) type construct is an example of a monad

Nullable (in the C# sense) does not form a monad, because it does not form a functor, because you cannot write fmap, because it does not nest.

Re:Category Theory for the Sciences by CarolineW on Saturday July 23, 2016 @02:57PM (#12150570)
Most people find abstract hard. I've seen how hard it is for people to really grok groups, and groups are comparatively trivial, with many concrete examples. The examples in Category Theory tend to be things that are themselves abstractions of things that are already quite abstract.
Re:Category Theory for the Sciences by tel on Saturday July 23, 2016 @02:39PM (#12150504)
It's hard to appreciate because to make the abstract nature valuable you need a body of concrete examples. You could probably do this halfway through an undergrad course, but it's not traditional. You can also do it with a body of programming knowledge.
Re:Category Theory for the Sciences by qcoh on Saturday July 23, 2016 @02:49PM (#12150537)
You need to know a few interesting categories and functors before you can appreciate it. Without that, it is really abstract nonsense.