News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by neom on Saturday July 23, 2016 @10:02AM (#12149477)
This article fails to address the growing divide between east coast and west coast technologist and entrepreneurs. Many of us in New York are ashamed and embarrassed by the valley, and are looking to change it via negation.
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by stephancoral on Saturday July 23, 2016 @10:37AM (#12149564)
Absolutely. I'm in NYC for HOPE this weekend. Coming from Silicon Valley where 1% of the workers are black, I was so happy to see such a huge diverse crowd at the conference, all there for the shared love of exploring technology and hacker culture. SV has some incredibly smart people but, in my experience, all they care about is making money. Feels like the hacker spirit has absolutely vanished
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 23, 2016 @12:01PM (#12149862)
As a NY (and India) guy who occasionally visits the west coast, seriously? NY loves tech but the valley only wants to make money?

Consider the blockchain. Out west they try and rebuild the world with it - consider the (thiel funded) urbit. Back east we just replace banking clearinghouses with bank built blockchain.

What makes you feel differently? Also curious what the ancestry of the people doing tech has to do with anything.

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by stephancoral on Sunday July 24, 2016 @09:42AM (#12153268)
Urbit, to me, is an elitist joke filled with needlessly obscurantist terminology. If it takes off I will eat my foot but I doubt it. To me it's just another example of the Valley bubble where they want "to change the world" but have no connection to the world they so desperately (for mostly egotistical reasons) seek to alter.

The NYC scene I've witnessed at HOPE is not nearly as pretentious as SV people. Whenever I hear "changing" or "rebuilding" the world my bullshit meter explodes. To me the NYC scene doesn't want to change the world in grand capitalistic gestures, they want to help out people and have information be free. I'm a big fan of 2600 and that whole ethos. Not to say SV is devoid of that, it's just so much more focused on the glitz and bullshit.

The ancestry / ethnicity of people in tech has to do with everything. Algorithms can be racist - whether it's insensitive snapchat filter (the Bob Marley one comes to mind) or facial detection algos that can't detect black people because the devs only tested it on lighter-skinned people. Diversity is a beautiful thing, especially in these polarizing times, and so its meaningful to me for there to be a large amount of different folk involved in our profession and interests. Only 1% of people working in Sv are black. That's just wrong.

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by yummyfajitas on Sunday July 24, 2016 @10:44AM (#12153441)
Urbit may or may not take off - I'm skeptical myself. But unlike most of the NY tech scene it is an attempt at replacing democracy with cryptographically secure monarchy (which I may be misrepresenting as "blockchain"). I can't imagine anyone in NY even attempting something like that - can you?

Algorithms failing to detect black people is not "racist." It's simply a reflection of the fact that contrast matters. Any algorithm out there will detect `5f(x) + noise` more accurately than `0.5 f(x) + noise`. Black people reflect fewer photons than white people, that's just how physics works. Why do you believe Black Americans can change this? And why can't dark skinned Tamils (probably the stereotypical data scientist) do the same thing?

I have absolutely no idea why you consider some specific demographic breakdown "just wrong". What's your underlying moral principle? The most I can come up with is some kind 1930's Italian style corporatism with certain specific ethnic groups as the corporates, but that seems uncharitable.

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by shanacarp on Monday July 25, 2016 @11:30PM (#12163148)
>Algorithms failing to detect black people is not "racist." It's simply a reflection of the fact that contrast matters. Any algorithm out there will detect `5f(x) + noise` more accurately than `0.5 f(x) + noise`. Black people reflect fewer photons than white people, that's just how physics works. Why do you believe Black Americans can change this? And why can't dark skinned Tamils (probably the stereotypical data scientist) do the same thing?

Actually, it is passively racist, since many of these algorithms have nothing to do with contrast and everything to do with improper tagging and insufficient and incorrect training data. It is how black people got labelled gorillas by google, and how I can name some names of how to get through a prominent AI/ML driven filter with Japanese woodblock shunga prints from the late Tokugawa period (go look it up yourself for examples)

Dark Skin Tamils can and should be part of developing tagging. I also tend to think that for things as complicated as porn or race, you may want to even do different training data in different places for different cultures. I don't honestly know how a Tamil would take an american's view on the imagery at the temple at Khajuraho in Madhya Pradesh. To many Americans, the sculptures on the temple may be outside the pale for work, but for a Hindu Tamil, it may be a place of great religious significance and may not bother them in the slightest.

> But unlike most of the NY tech scene it is an attempt at replacing democracy with cryptographically secure monarchy (which I may be misrepresenting as "blockchain"). I can't imagine anyone in NY even attempting something like that - can you?

The better question is why? Even Hobbes hated monarchies, he just thought they were the best of bad options under the conditions of you magically get a benevolent ruler, and only because he lived through too many radical revolutions in england. Almost everyone else disagrees with him.

What happens when you are on the outs with your monarch/dictator. What is your counterweight in the state to have real rights? (bitcoins and the blockchain are not them, especially for a mass group)

How do you plan on dealing with that?

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by Canada on Saturday July 23, 2016 @01:52PM (#12150297)
I don't think Urbit uses a blockchain at all.
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by igk on Saturday July 23, 2016 @12:07PM (#12149889)
To be honest? I'll take 5% more efficient banks. The boring stuff is usually worth a lot more to Society. Just doesn't catch us tweens less easily

Also, if you've followed the urbit guys from the start, then you know how cultlike they are. No thanks

Source:am tween

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by Tycho on Saturday July 23, 2016 @02:05PM (#12150356)
would the customer notice any difference if bank were 5% more efficient?
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by alex_c on Saturday July 23, 2016 @10:29AM (#12149542)
I'm not a member of either community - can you expand on the difference you see between the two?
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by neom on Saturday July 23, 2016 @11:06AM (#12149679)
Some people are building toys for children, some people are building tools for humans. Both are fine, in moderation.

I think we see more and more the NYC tech culture feels like they are trying to build real things, the valley is stuck in consumerism and has lost the ability to push the needle, much of this is due to poorly considered greed and linear thinking. :(

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by econner on Saturday July 23, 2016 @11:53AM (#12149817)
What a sweeping generalization. Can you provide any justification that the valley has "lost the ability to push the needle?"
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by neom on Sunday July 24, 2016 @10:23AM (#12153382)
Just look at the general investment philosophy of any VC below T1.
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by 650REDHAIR on Saturday July 23, 2016 @11:50AM (#12149806)
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by sievebrain on Saturday July 23, 2016 @11:36AM (#12149774)
What is "linear thinking"?
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by w1ntermute on Saturday July 23, 2016 @11:40AM (#12149783)
It's one of those buzzwordy terms currently in vogue in the tech industry. It's a hipper way of saying "not creative/disruptive". The b-school equivalent would be "thinking inside the box". For example, here's sama (president of YC)[0]:

> Very rare and extremely powerful combination: the ability to think both clearly and very non-linearly. Most people lucky to have one.

An example of nonlinear thinking by sama[1]:

> the company wanted to come visit our offices so they could make sure we were a 'real' company. At that time, we were only 5 guys. So we hired a bunch of our college friends to 'work' for us for the day so we could look larger than we actually were. It worked, and we got the contract.

As you might expect, Peter Thiel prefers to be a contrarian and use his own term for it: Zero to One[2].

0. https://www.twitter.com/sama/status/699330028404772864

1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3048944

2. https://www.amazon.com/Zero-One-Notes-Startups-Future/dp/080...

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by markonthewall on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @02:45PM (#12212224)
Afaik the folks at F8 started the trend, I heard them use that idiom back in 2009 (F8 didn't exist yet)
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by pohungc on Saturday July 23, 2016 @11:50AM (#12149809)
What are some of the most impactful things being built in the NYC tech scene?
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by shanacarp on Monday July 25, 2016 @11:42PM (#12163186)
So there are actually other things being built in NYC that are very not scenish at all.

Like Vroom - no one talks about the used car market, but they are huge. Knewton and Schoology, two other big company no one treats as huge unless you are into ed-tech Kinnek just raised a huge round, they are trying to be an amazon of suppliers

All of these things are impactful, but, well, weird. There are a LOT of those types of things in NYC

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by neom on Sunday July 24, 2016 @10:27AM (#12153391)
pinterest, etsy, fab, digitalocean, buzzfeed, any media platform, guilt, foursquare, seamless web, app nexsus, etc. I could literally list 100.
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by 650REDHAIR on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @12:28AM (#12170528)
So pinterest, fab, buzzfeed, guilt, and foursquare are "tools for humans" and startups like, oh I don't know, Tesla in SV/SF, are toys?
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by neom on Thursday August 04, 2016 @04:56PM (#12228414)
You named Tesla, bravo...?
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by abhi3 on Saturday July 23, 2016 @01:04PM (#12150110)
theskimm, buzzfeed
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by wavefunction on Saturday July 23, 2016 @11:12AM (#12149702)
Of course there are more than just the coasts.
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by vpribish on Saturday July 23, 2016 @11:54AM (#12149822)
please cite some examples
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by SomeCallMeTim on Saturday July 23, 2016 @12:22PM (#12149953)
Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by Turing_Machine on Saturday July 23, 2016 @02:24PM (#12150447)
University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. Georgia Tech (okay, that's technically in the east, but it's not what's usually thought of as "East Coast"). UT Austin. University of Wisconsin—​Madison. University of Michigan—​Ann Arbor.

The list could go on. If you want to expand outward a bit, the University of Waterloo in Canada is also quite good.

Re:What Silicon Valley Insiders Think of Peter Thiel’s Speec... by nickthemagicman on Saturday July 23, 2016 @12:03PM (#12149871)
lol. check mate.