News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by vonmoltke on Friday July 22, 2016 @10:57AM (#12143912)
> Yahoo (net of BABA) is less than worthless.

This fallacy needs to die. You cannot just subtract the value of Alibaba and declare the company "less than worthless". Company valuations don't work that way

Yahoo has significant debt. If Yahoo were willing and able to liquidate Alibaba or Yahoo Japan the proceeds would be used, at least partially, to pay off that debt. You cannot stick all of the company's debt on a select portion of the business and declare it worthless based on that.

Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by bogomipz on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:49PM (#12146288)
Isn't the problem with them divesting both of those entities - Alibaba and Yahoo Japan, the outsized tax burden from the sale? I thought this was the reason it was a non-starter this past year.
Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by vonmoltke on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:59PM (#12146345)
Possibly, but I notice the vast majority of the deferred tax burden Yahoo has came on to the books at roughly the same time as the Alibaba investment, so the tax hit may already be reflected in the balance sheet.

Edit (the numbers):

Long-term investments: 31DEC13: $5B -> 31DEC14: $44.6B

Deferred Long Term Liability Charges: 31DEC13: $1.1B -> 31DEC14: $17.1B

Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by mikeash on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:16PM (#12144467)
The article talks about efforts to spin off the BABA part. Verizon is only buying certain pieces of Yahoo. Is it really that absurd to talk about the different pieces?
Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by vonmoltke on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:03PM (#12144864)
It is absurd to talk about separate assets without talking about where the liabilities go. Yahoo has over $16B in total liabilities. You cannot attach all the liabilities of a company to a specific part of its assets.
Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by mikeash on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:26PM (#12145077)
OK, so where do all the liabilities go in this case?
Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by vonmoltke on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:37PM (#12145182)
That depends on how the deal is structured and what happens to the other pieces. This is where mergers and acquisitions get complicated. Part of Verizon's price tag might be assumed liabilities from Yahoo. Maybe part of the Alibaba stake gets sold to cover them. Maybe it stays with whatever the holding company remnant will be. Can't tell from just a public balance sheet and a headline. However, assuming Verzion is going to take on all $16B of Yahoo's liabilities when they are getting a relatively small portion of the assets is ludicrous.
Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by mikeash on Friday July 22, 2016 @02:31PM (#12145656)
Makes sense. Do I understand correctly, then, that Verizon is taking on an unknown amount of Yahoo's debt as part of this deal, with the exact quantity to be determined by what the two parties negotiate, and until that's known it's pointless to talk about the net value of the piece that Verizon is buying?
Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by vonmoltke on Friday July 22, 2016 @04:04PM (#12146379)
Good question. As I pointed out above, after looking at the balance sheet history, it appears that the bulk of Yahoo's liabilities are tied to the Alibaba investment. Those liabilities will understandably follow that asset, and shows just how ridiculous the math is that people here are using here. Alibaba is not worth what is on the asset side. It is worth that value minus the liabilities specifically tied to that asset.
Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by jack9 on Friday July 22, 2016 @11:42AM (#12144205)
> You cannot just subtract the value of Alibaba and declare the company "less than worthless".

I can and do.

> Company valuations don't work that way

I disagree, except if you care to shell out <10 million and say "see it's worth something!" which is disingenuous. The amount to maintain the remnants will dwarf the cost of acquisition, making it a net loss.

Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by vonmoltke on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:06PM (#12144890)
> I can and do.

Then you're wrong. That isn't how company book value works. A company's book value is the total of its assets minus the total of its liabilities. Removing an asset from the calculation without adjusting the liabilities is just wrong. It isn't proper accounting.

> I disagree, except if you care to shell out <10 million and say "see it's worth something!" which is disingenuous. The amount to maintain the remnants will dwarf the cost of acquisition, making it a net loss.

What numbers do you have to support this? What portion of Yahoo's liabilities are coming along with the assets Verizon wants to buy?

Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by Yhippa on Friday July 22, 2016 @02:13PM (#12145494)
You are correct for market value: http://www.investopedia.com/stock-analysis/070215/why-yahoos...

> Yahoo’s total market cap is less than the $40.5 billion, and after accounting for the cash on the company’s balance sheet, this means Yahoo’s core business is valued at less than $0. Now, this isn’t a new development that will disappear with some quick arbitrage. In fact, the value of Yahoo’s core business has been negatively valued for more than a year, so investors are seeing the value discrepancy measured by traditional means but just don’t believe in the company’s trajectory.

Re:Verizon nears deal to acquire Yahoo by vonmoltke on Friday July 22, 2016 @02:26PM (#12145609)
That article is making a different mistake. It is looking at market cap versus total assets. That isn't a very good measure and does not mean investors place negative value on the core business. Yahoo's book value is only about $27B, which is the amount that would be left if the company were liquidated today (notwithstanding liquidation costs). Since their price/book ratio is greater than 1 it means investors do put value on the future business, albeit not very much.