News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by brador on Friday July 22, 2016 @05:02AM (#12142469)
Question: what happens to land rights after a quake? Since the quake moves land around, stretching in parts and destroying land into cracks in others. Do property lines get redrawn? Who owns any newly created land space? Is it fair game for anyone to claim?
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by Animats on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:45PM (#12146254)
California has the Cullen Earthquake Act to deal with that.[1] That's a consolidation law, so that all the claims in an affected area can be resolved in one court proceeding.

[1] http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=ccp&gr...

Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by whoopdedo on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:36PM (#12146185)
You should ask the residents of Hollister.

http://www.bldgblog.com/2015/04/the-town-that-creep-built/

Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by celticninja on Friday July 22, 2016 @05:09AM (#12142496)
It doest really work like that, it's not like new land is created by pushing out into the sea, but even if it was the property owners boundary is likely the sea, therefore the land is incorporated within their area.
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by JshWright on Friday July 22, 2016 @05:35AM (#12142576)
It very much does work like that though... The San Andreas fault is a "strike-slip" fault. The plates are (effectively) moving past each other, in opposite directions.

Imagine you owned a rectangular piece of land, with the fault running right up through the middle of it. After an earthquake, the western half of your property is now shifted a non-trivial distance to the north relative to the eastern half. What happens to the property line? Does it now have a 'kink' in it? Does it remain in the same place relative to the 'ideal' geodesic plane (meaning various landmark like fenceposts, etc, are now in a different place relative to the property line).

It's certainly an interesting question...

Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by evgen on Friday July 22, 2016 @05:50AM (#12142631)
You have ownership of a piece of land, not a spot on a map. If the land moves then you still own the land even if it is non-contiguous. I am not sure what happens in the case where some event creates new land adjacent to yours such as the case where a lava flow extends land out past yours into what was once water or if an uplift fault raises seabed to become contiguous with yours, but I would assume that the state would claim ownership over the new land.
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by ptaipale on Friday July 22, 2016 @06:21AM (#12142708)
What happens to "newly created land" depends on local legislation. Where I live (Finland) this is a common question, because it happens all the time. We're still recovering from the depression of ground, caused by latest Ice Age. In Western Finland and Eastern Sweden, the land rises at about 1 cm per year, thus claiming area from the sea.

1 cm per year may not sound like a lot, but in shallow waters, it means that entire coastal towns become inland towns over the course of 100 years. Harbours have to be relocated, etc. Kilometres of new land is claimed from the sea over the course of centuries (and within a couple of millenia, the Gulf of Bothnia will dry up in places and create a land connection across, assuming water level rise caused by global climate change does not slow it down too much).

Over here, the law works so that the newly created land at the shore becomes property of the owner of the water area (fishing) rights which is a "commonwealth" of local land owners, but the owner of the particular piece of land formerly adjacent to the sea or lake has the pre-emptive right to purchase the area and attach it to his/her property, at a "fair" price i.e. price comparable to the price of his/her own property. So in effect you have to remember to buy regularly (every few decades) the new land between your plot and the water.

But that was Finland. How does this work regarding land created or lost in earthquakes in California? Let's assume that the fault line of tectonic plates happens to run through your plot, the plates push at each other and then in an earthquake run over each other, and the corner points of your plot move closer to each other. Is that just your loss? I.e. your plot became smaller? And likewise, if the borders of your plot move away from each other in an earthquake, your property expands, possibly impacting e.g. how large buildings can be constructed according to zoning regulations?

Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by hueving on Friday July 22, 2016 @06:39AM (#12142762)
>You have ownership of a piece of land, not a spot on a map.

That's sort of silly. How do you define a 'piece of land'? What if I dig out my piece of land so it's a 100ft hole and then there is a sheering motion from the plates so half of my hole slides under someone else's land? Do I still own both halves? If so, do I no longer own the land at the bottom of the top half? If not, then it would not seem that I do not own a 'piece of land'.

Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by ptaipale on Friday July 22, 2016 @08:24AM (#12143105)
Land ownership is not really absolute; it is always subject to the definitions of the local law and, ultimately, the whims of the government.

You don't have complete power over what you do to your land, because the government has the last word. On the other hand, without government, there is no land ownership because the definition and enforcement of land ownership is one of the most ultimate functions of any government, since the creation of first city-states (e.g. ancient Babylon).

So if the government permits you to dig that hole in the first place, then what happens in an earthquake depends on local legislation. I don't really know how it works e.g. in the U.S. but I would assume that the boundary of your piece of land is defined in relation to physical markers that are recorded with their geocoordinates, but if the lay of the land changes so that the markers move, then the boundary of your plot will also move. And this could mean that the size of your plot changes.

Where I live, for instance, there are old boundary stones (which would in an earthquake naturally move along with the land on which they are laid) and newer marker bolts attached to bedrock that serve as reference points for geodesic measurement purposes. Also, there are height markers; for instance, when I started to build my house, the city would send a guy with equipment and start from one of these markers and then tell me if the foundations of the house are at right elevation. Should there be a major earthquake (not really a possibility here, ours is just about the most stable bedrock on Earth) then the changed positions (coordinates) would have to be recorded in land registry.

Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by GregBuchholz on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:04PM (#12145901)
You may find learning more about the foundations of common-law to be interesting (since it seems you are from a Civil Law perspective).

http://faculty.msb.edu/hasnasj/GTWebSite/TortWeb.html

http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=586941

Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by ptaipale on Friday July 22, 2016 @05:10PM (#12146797)
Thanks, these were interesting reads, although I would still appreciate a hint how common law specifically would handle emergence of new land differently from civil law systems?
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by int_19h on Friday July 22, 2016 @04:13PM (#12146436)
A piece of land is typically defined in terms of geographic coordinates, though. Which do not move when the physical solids constituting your land do.
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by kalleboo on Saturday July 23, 2016 @04:41AM (#12148841)
But not always - my parents own land in Australia and one of their borders is defined as meeting a river (since the river is publicly-owned so anyone can get water from it). When the river changes, they gain or lose land.
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by celticninja on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:55PM (#12144808)
I imagine if you have boundary markers, such as a fence line, that would remain your boundary line. Without a physically marked boundary line then you would be stuck with the shape as shown on maps.
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by chiph on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:51PM (#12146299)
Trade an easement for $1 with the neighbors to return the parcel to a usable shape.
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by slazaro on Friday July 22, 2016 @05:22AM (#12142537)
But what if you have a fence that gets shifted around, and no longer matches the boundaries in the property maps?
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by brador on Friday July 22, 2016 @05:30AM (#12142558)
Say there's a crack or fissure that opens up, creating new "space". Someone then fills that crack with soil making new "land". Or say the land under a fence moves. Since land ownership diagrams contain specific measurements, are they redrawn? Replaced? Accepted? Measurements ignored and features used instead (apple tree to 7th fence post)?

If my property deed says my yard is 20 metres wide, but post earthquake it's 21 because a 1 metre wide split occured in it what happens when I sell? Is accuracy thrown out the window?

Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by evgen on Friday July 22, 2016 @05:53AM (#12142636)
My best guess would be that the state would claim original ownership of the new land. If you take a small coastal lot and then start building landfill out into the ocean you are going to have a hard time convincing the state that you own the property without some pre-existing contract with the appropriate regulatory bodies stating this when you started construction.
[dead]
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by spdustin on Friday July 22, 2016 @06:55PM (#12147358)
I don't think that's it at all. It seemed to me to be a purely intellectual curiosity, and one that I share. The logistics of something like the redrawing of property lines after the land itself has moved is well outside of our wheelhouse for most of us, I suspect the answer elucidated in a sibling of your comment was interesting to quite a few people.
Re:How long should we wait for an overdue earthquake on the ... by noobermin on Friday July 22, 2016 @02:46PM (#12145765)
Question: what happens to your IP when it ends up on a torrent and the world copies it all over?

Human institutions do not win against nature/reality. Not that we shouldn't try, but we have to remember that our institutions are limited ultimately by the laws of physics and mathematics/statistics.