News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maths notation is needlessly complex [video] by lisper on Thursday July 21, 2016 @06:55PM (#12140618)
I can't quite figure out which side you're arguing here. On the one hand you say that the triangle notation is awesome, but then you go on to use linear strings of symbols in exactly the manner that I was advocating. The whole point of the triangle notation (and all spatial notations in math -- subscripts, superscripts, the various arguments to sums, products, and integrals, etc) is that it's two-dimensional. That makes it really hard to render into ascii, which is one of the many reasons I think it's a bad idea.

I am certainly not arguing against teaching higher level concepts.

Re:Maths notation is needlessly complex [video] by nnq on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:23AM (#12141679)
> The whole point of the triangle notation is that it's two-dimensional.

Nope. I'm arguing that what the OP calls "triangle notation" is just a particular representation of a cool idea. The idea actually happens to be independent of how you happen to represent it. Yes, it lends itself well to 2D scribling. but the real reason I find it's cool, and useful to more than schoolchildren is that it's a much deeper idea in disguise. I think the author doesn't even realize how awesome is the idea he's promoting and why...

P.S. And about sides: generally, when I enter a 2-sided argument, I pretend to support one but argue for neither or for both at the same time, and from the argument I try to pull out a 3rd side (yup, I love triangles) that no one has yes seen, offering a fresh perspective. You can never have enough opposing points of view :)

Re:Maths notation is needlessly complex [video] by lisper on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:48AM (#12141930)
We may be in violent agreement here. I agree that the idea being communicated is a cool idea. I just don't think the triangle notation actually contributes much to the effective communication of that idea.
Re:Maths notation is needlessly complex [video] by nnq on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:47AM (#12141745)
And...

> That makes it really hard to render into ascii, which is one of the many reasons I think it's a bad idea.

...this is one idea that I really dislike. We have touchscreens everywhere, soon 3D glasses everywhere, a whole plethora of input devices, and at some point we'll have usable direct electric bran-computer-interfaces. Why limit to ASCII?! Heck, even 3D is not enough in my mind - you can "easily" imagine RGB color displayed on 3D objects as a secondary attached 3D space, hence boom, you can "easily" (probably not for most, but with enough training doable) visualize 4 (3 space + 1 time) + 3 (r, g, b) = 7 dimensions using sight alone!

Heck even programming languages should move away from 1.5D text. I can't wait to see the first really cool visual syntaxes. I imagine that the Perl 6 equivalent of a visual 2D/3D programming language combined with a more useful input device than a keyboard would look awe inspiring!

Imagine how cool would it be to play with 7D mathematical notations and to what cool insights they will lead :) (though for teaching and publication 2D is probably enough for math as the cool thing about math is still that you can do it with just pen and paper or in you head while using the 3D-processing part of your mind do things like walk on the street...)

Re:Maths notation is needlessly complex [video] by lisper on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:47AM (#12141928)
> Why limit to ASCII?!

Because it's precise and unambiguous, like math should be but often isn't. And it's easy to manipulate with code, so that makes it easy to enlist the help of computers to help with the work.