News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maths notation is needlessly complex [video] by wongarsu on Thursday July 21, 2016 @02:50PM (#12139106)
>I'm pretty sure everyone thinks visually or geometrically or spatially or something like that. Most certainly visually if you're not blind.

I don't think visually or geometrically or spatially or something like that.

I'm naturally thinking in terms of words and abstract concepts. Visualizing something in my mind is actual work; you can describe a person to me in minute detail without me ever visualizing what they might look like. My sense of direction sucks, and I typically don't solve problems visually (or geometrically or spatially).

Of course I can still convert between thoughts and images (though conversion between thoughts and words is often easier), and sometimes a problem is easier to explain visually. I understand your proof and find it satisfactory, but it took me some time and I would have prefered a proof by induction.

Re:Maths notation is needlessly complex [video] by jordigh on Thursday July 21, 2016 @03:42PM (#12139468)
What about being convinced that local extrema of smooth functions occur when the derivative is zero? You find it easier to work through an epsilon-delta algebraic proof than to look at a graph and see that it's flat wherever there's a local extremum? Do you find graphs to represent data useless and you would rather look at long lists of numbers?
Re:Maths notation is needlessly complex [video] by wongarsu on Thursday July 21, 2016 @06:43PM (#12140569)
The derivative is the rate of change. If I chose any two points to the left and right to the local extremum, they are non-zero and have different signs. Since there has to be a zero between those two points, the local extremum must have a derivative of zero.

That's the line of reasoning I would go. Looking at a graph, searching for exceptions and concluding that there aren't any is probably as easy in this case. Like probably most people I have a harder time thinking about epsilon-delta proofs.

>Do you find graphs to represent data useless and you would rather look at long lists of numbers?

No, graphs are great. They sacrifice precision to show simple relations between large amounts of numbers, and are really good at that. Numbers a row of numbers can't do that (the closest equivalent to a line graph is to replace each but the first number with their difference to the previous number, but that's still inferior). Natural language is lacking precision at reasonable density for the job.

So graphs are pretty much the only decent tool for their job we have invented so far.