tl;dr the SEC was worried that the explosion in house prices during the 90s (which raised many people's net worth above the accreditation threshold set in 1982) and the parallel increase in both the popularity and complexity of private investment offerings were tempting many people out of their financial depth. Large numbers of people borrowing against the value of their home to invest in hot deals without much understanding of the risks involved struck the SEC as a dangerous situation.
Arguably, the events of the last few years proved them correct. The SEC was not trying to strangle startups (nor was it blind to the the possibility of such a result), but to maintain a barrier between overconfident homeowners and glib fund managers whose only business case was that markets tend to rise over time.
- Whatever the problem is, is it a problem?
- Does this solve it?
- Who is paying/lobbying Dodd to do this? I imagine it wasn't on his radar until someone who stands to gain brought it to his attention. Is it just Tourette legislation?
- If the result will be as bad as the article says ... how/why do we let Congress get away with fucking things up?