News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by tlb on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @12:12PM (#1213260)
Good for him. Having money would disrupt his life and set back his work. I'm waiting to see what he comes up with next.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by rdtsc on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @12:28PM (#1213302)
He has abandonded mathematics. I don't know what he works on now.

Currently he mentions that he has everything he wants and doesn't want to be paraded like an animal in the zoo for everyone to see. He doesn't want money and honors.

What has alienated him from mathematics is others dishonesty. Read the "Manifold Destiny" article from New Yorker by Sylvia Nasar and David Gruber (http://www.newyorker.com/archive/2006/08/28/060828fa_fact2). In there you'll find a reference to Shing-Tung Yau. Quote from the article:

As for Yau, Perelman said, “I can’t say I’m outraged. Other people do worse. Of course, there are many mathematicians who are more or less honest. But almost all of them are conformists. They are more or less honest, but they tolerate those who are not honest.”

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by caxap on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @08:16PM (#1214482)
Next time when I want to publish a paper, I will take the work of someone else, claim that it's unreadable and difficult to understand, "clarify" parts that were unreadable, and put my name on it. I just cannot believe that things like that are common practice for some researchers. That was a great read, thanks.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by raganwald on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @09:39PM (#1214667)
And then use your ill-gotten fame to seek out grants and funding from governments and philanthropists to further your goals.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by raganwald on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @01:17PM (#1213446)
A tremendous article, thank you for the link.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by cynicalkane on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @12:18PM (#1213275)
It's strange that people allow their lives to be disrupted by money. It seems like if you won a million, you can continue living the life you have now plus $1 million in CDs or something.

To me, the negative effect that windfall amounts of money have on a lot of people is the barest example of how people often function better under constraints. Living freely is hard.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by praptak on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @12:55PM (#1213384)
"It seems like if you won a million, you can continue living the life you have now plus $1 million in CDs or something."

Maybe if nobody knows that you've got the million (not the case here.) Otherwise the money may draw unwanted attention - "friends" asking you to lend them some or even criminals trying to convince you to part with the money.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by iskander on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @02:31PM (#1213659)
This is especially a problem in Russia, where having even modest sums can draw the attention of local goons. I don't think being a famous mathematician is any protection from having Grisha the neighborhood limb breaker show up at your door.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by rdtsc on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @03:03PM (#1213750)
I never thought of it that way. But that is certainly a interesting angle to it. He might be puting himself and his mom in danger if others thought he has a $1m.

Anyone in Russia who has that kind of money also has body guards and private mansions with tall electrified fences.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by petercooper on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @07:17PM (#1214362)
My life plays the lottery and I've thought about this stuff before. I believe you have to do publicity here and there's no way I'd want to live where I do now with people knowing what we look like and how much we won.

(Not that I would anyway, I'd be throwing $500k down on an EB-5 and moving all of our asses to California. But still..)

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by Hexstream on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @01:51PM (#1216350)
Can you really get all that with $1m and still have some money left?...
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by borism on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @05:37PM (#1214120)
Not that he's any safer if he doesn't accept the money - local limb breaker may come and try to convince him to take it or more probably won't even know whether he accepted or not.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by hrabago on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @08:35PM (#1214517)
This reminds me of a story about how Manu Ginobili's family, who refused to move to the US, has to live with police protection to keep from being kidnapped.

I can't find the exact story I read from before, though.

http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/news/story?id=1839968

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by nearestneighbor on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @10:36PM (#1214768)
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by dschobel on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @12:30PM (#1213315)
Set back his work? From every public account available the man has completely given up mathematics.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by qjz on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @01:01PM (#1213394)
There is other work besides mathematics.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by fnid2 on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @02:40PM (#1213684)
It's amazing how anti-content this group is. The man doesn't want more money and people are attacking him.

Isn't that odd?

I admire him.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by jimmyjim on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @05:22PM (#1214078)
It is selfish for the intellectually gifted to not give back the gifts of new knowledge.

Perelman has given fruits, but being as selfish as he is now makes him as good as dead. Imagine if Ramanujan had went back to India and given up just after the Ramanujan conjecture. Or if Erdos had called it quits shortly after working on the probabilistic method.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by pavs on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @05:47PM (#1214139)
How is he selfish? He doesn't owe anyone anything.

> Perelman has given fruits, but being as selfish as he is now makes him as good as dead.

This is one of the dumbest and offensive thing I have read here in YN.

> Imagine if Ramanujan had went back to India and given up just after the Ramanujan conjecture. Or if Erdos had called it quits shortly after working on the probabilistic method.

And what would happen? Nothing. Humanity will still be here without their contribution.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by igorhvr on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @06:03AM (#1215363)
It was truly painful to read this comment. When you read books like Atlas shrugged, you see them talking about a horrible kind of moral - but it is hard to believe there really is such people (I know better, already, but still..) - and here it is, on display.

Let me list the stupid assumptions contained on those lines:

* New knowledge is simply a gift - not a product of effort. * People that produce knowledge have obligation of giving it to society. * On the top of it, now he is now "as good as dead". So let me see if I understood: leeches like jimmyjim (who probably never produced anything useful in his life) should be allowed to go on, while people like Perelman - who already given us a very valuable gift - should now die? Because he is tired, or refuses to continue to do so? Is he some kind of slave to humanity?

> Imagine if Ramanujan had went back to India and given up just after the Ramanujan conjecture. Maybe he would have a happier life for himself and his family? Maybe he would change and become a great writer? A mass murderer? A drunk? Who fucking cares, and why the fuck does it matter? It is his life, and he can do whatever he wants with it.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by jimmyjim on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @05:28PM (#1216941)
I regret saying that he's "as good as dead". My excuse is that I was sleep-deprived and frustrated for personal reasons when I wrote that.

That said, let's imagine another scenario. In a late night, your mother is being raped right before my eyes. It is my moral obligation to report this, isn't it? Of course, I can choose to exercise my free right and not report this incident, because, it's my life, and I can do whatever I want with it... but if I have the capability to do so, I think I should rather satisfy my moral obligation. But maybe that's just me. And maybe you'd see better if you pulled your head out of Ayn Rand's arse.

Perelman has the capacity and capability to give fascinating gifts of knowledge to this world, and I hope that we all come to respect his wishes (to honor him in a way that it doesn't offend him), so that the newfound knowledge is used for good to better mankind.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by Vivtek on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @10:10AM (#1215700)
Maybe JimmyJim is exercising very subtle humor here.

That's what I'm choosing to believe, anyway.

Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by Methos on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @07:40PM (#1214415)
yeah...i totally agree with you...rather i say, we should pass a law and punish those f'kin genius bastards for being smart. Lets just force them to innovate and sell it to the society for free...after all they owe us... hmm .. hmm .. ohh wait but what if they go on strike.. shrugs .. who cares?
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by mpk on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @09:53PM (#1214691)
Nice Atlas reference.
Re:Perelman declines 1M prize: "I have everything I want" by borism on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @05:39PM (#1214124)
it's a personal choice - nothing for us to be judgmental about.