News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by grandalf on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:28PM (#12132239)
> you are absolutely not describing a political movement. You are describing a militia through and through.

The point I'm making is that all political movements want to control people, which entails the direct or indirect use of force. Pro/anti choice activists in the US may not use suicide bombers, but they want to get a law passed that will jail people who do the thing they don't like (perform abortions vs have abortions). This is indirect use of lethal force, because it has been effectively institutionalized in the US.

It's idealistic or naive to believe that political movements do not exist for the purpose of exerting direct or indirect lethal force on others. This is a cynical view but it is true (though there are other motives for movements/organizations to exist, those exist alongside obtaining power/influence).

Drone pilots do not have to be zealots in order to fly a drone into a village and unleash a payload on a bungalow full of people, they must simply go through military training. Propaganda indoctrination is part of the US military's training approach, because studies have found that humans really don't like killing other humans if they think of them as human. The propaganda makes it psychologically easier for soldiers to follow orders and do their job.

Surely a so-called zealot who is doing a suicide bombing believes some similar sort of propaganda. Many American soldiers have bravely charged into combat zones with full knowledge there was a good chance they would perish. Why imagine a suicide bomber as fundamentally different when he is fundamentally similar?

Yes, ISIS does some really nasty things and appears to have no redeeming characteristics whatsoever. It's fine to disapprove of those things, but I think it's unfair to focus on the inevitable moral differences in an asymmetric conflict... they always exist. The British were outraged that the revolutionary soldiers would take cover behind a tree to take aim.

The moral tolerance that each side has for outrageous acts is context dependent. There is not any cultural/institutional superiority or inferiority involved. Our own military leaders know this and are ready to do whatever is necessary to get results (see Rumsfeld's strong defense of torture techniques).

So moral outrage about ISIS is part of the propaganda message to encourage Americans to support the war. Many people have died in the war so far, and it is not Americans that are dying, it's the brown skinned people we wantonly slaughter. This is abetted by the perception that the groups are illegitimate and morally bankrupt. It is we who are imposing our will on people thousands of miles away so that we can take natural resources from their land.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:34PM (#12132279)
This jumping from 'its a law' to "the government will kill you" is sophomoric. Its repeated on HN from time to time. Laws are to inform, and to help folks conform to expectations, and yes sometimes result in somebody being fined or even incarcerated. Its not all about killing everybody.

I suppose all food is death too! Because everybody who eats, dies. Such claptrap was fun to talk about in college; lets get past this kind of cheap philosophizing.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by grandalf on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:56PM (#12132446)
> This jumping

Not sure where you perceive this jump as having occurred. My point is just that force is a part of any government, arguably a necessary part, which is why fledgling governments often focus on it.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by JoeAltmaier on Thursday July 21, 2016 @12:07AM (#12134569)
All that sophomoric doubletalk about 'lethal force' thrown in there for effect I guess
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by grandalf on Thursday July 21, 2016 @11:45AM (#12137601)
I don't see how it's sophomoric or "double talk". Control/institutionalization of lethal force is something governments do in the following ways:

- supply police and military with weapons and authorize killing during conflict (defensive or offensive)

- perform executions of those sentenced to death

- punish those who try to use lethal force without permission (murderers)

- to wield and threaten the use of force in order to achieve some objective (domestically or internationally). The presidential motorcade is essentially a parade of tanks that happen to look like limousines.

Hence, transitioning from a state of relative anarchy to a state of governance requires the institutionalization of lethal force.

There is a great deal of variability in the ways force is used, some of which we view as just and others as unjust. The details of this are not relevant to my broader point, which is simply that force and governance are deeply intertwined.

If you are a high class member of society, the force generally all works on your behalf. If you are a low class member, it may often work against you. The edge cases (a cop shooting someone at a traffic stop) tend to effect lower class members disproportionally.

It's idealistic to believe that in a majoritarian democracy, even the democratically chosen reasonable uses of force are fair to everyone they impact.

I'm not sure which specific points you disagree with, so it is difficult to address them, but if you still disagree I'm willing to try.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by JoeAltmaier on Thursday July 21, 2016 @06:17PM (#12140465)
No 'hence' about it. Those are just a tiny listing of what government does. Tribesmen in the jungle govern themselves without doing any of those things. Some current nations, for whatever reason, don't do those things. Yet they are certainly governed.

To blow 'use of lethal force' into the be-all and end-all of the purpose of government is over the top rhetoric.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by grandalf on Thursday July 21, 2016 @07:59PM (#12140903)
> To blow 'use of lethal force' into the be-all and end-all of the purpose of government is over the top rhetoric.

If your counterexample is what tribesmen in the jungle allegedly do, I think that's evidence that I've hit upon a fairly universal quality :)

I'm not sure how you perceive my use of the point as a rhetorical ploy. I introduced the idea into the discussion to emphasize a key similarity between ISIS and other governments... Except in anarchy (or perhaps in jungle tribes) someone will control lethal force. In a majoritarian democracy the majority does, sometimes tyrannically.

In a fledgling grassroots Islamist movement, the same requirement exists, but it's handled differently... so differently that my analogy seems inappropriate to some.

Political groups are aggregators of power. Those who want power gravitate toward them. I de-emphasize whether the sort of power desired is financial, coercive (force oriented), sexual, or ideological... all scratch the same primitive itch.

So it follows that ISIS will seek all of these kinds of power in order to become a respected and dominant institution in the region.