News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by tptacek on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:02AM (#12129055)
You don't even have to support an Islamist Turkey to have problems with military coups. I think Erdogan is highly problematic and that the direction Turkey is taking will materially harm a generation of its people. But even that is a better outcome than a military coup!

I don't like Islamist governments (any more than I'd like a Christian Fundamentalist government here --- "Christian", by the way, being a word that could fairly be applied to me), but I too get the strong sense that the only factor being weighed by supporters of the coup on this thread, whether they're well-informed enough to invoke Ataturk or not, is "Islamism bad, anything else good". No.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by grandalf on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:21AM (#12129191)
Exactly.

In the US, the word "Islamism" comes with a payload that is a gift-wrapped propaganda message:

- Islamism will trend toward and harbor fundamentalist "strains".

- Islamism cannot be pluralistic or largely secular due to structural reasons or ideological invariants.

- An Islamist political system is permanently at odds with the sort of Enlightenment values that guide the West.

I've read a lot of very serious arguments that claim that Western pluralism and democracy were largely germinated by doctrinal aspects of Christianity.

Quotes like the "Render unto Caesar" passage are hailed as the cornerstone of the separation of church and state, and Islam, lacking the equivalent, is deemed to devalue such separation... Even things like the Schism of 1054 are hailed as helping to usher in the values of representative democracy.