News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How We Teach Introductory Computer Science Is Wrong by yummyfajitas on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @09:21AM (#1212818)
While I agree that this method might help in Algebra/intro to CS, I'm not sure it's beneficial in the long run. The net result is the following set of expectations: you teach them how to apply an algorithm, then they repeat what you told them on the test. This is nothing more than "teaching to the test".

This is, for the most part, how students are taught in high school.

The problem is the following: real life and (if you are doing your job right) more advanced classes don't fit this model. A simple linear algebra example (from my midterm two weeks ago) illustrates what happens when students are taught this way.

Problem: a 4k x 4k matrix M consists of 4x4 blocks along the diagonal, 4x4 blocks on the bottom row, and zeros elsewhere. Find an efficient algorithm for computing M v (v a vector).

    [ M1 0  0 ... 0 ]
    [ 0  M2 0 ... 0 ]
    [ ...           ]
    [ B1 B2 ...   Bk]
The right answer consists of multiplying only the non-zero blocks and has complexity O(k). I gave partial credit for any answer that computed M v. The most common answer I got was "compute the LU factorization." Some went so far as to explain how to use the LU factorization to solve Mx = v. Apparently, I used the word "efficient" when explaining the purpose of the LU factorization, and I used the word "efficient" in this problem.

My students were trained for 12 years to repeat the teachers password. This training failed them the moment they needed to think. It may improve performance in the short term, and it's an easy way to teach. But the long term results are extremely harmful.

There are no comments on this comment yet.