Re:Usenet Tradecraft: Survival in an Extremely Adversarial E...
by vinceguidry on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:42AM
(#12129348)
> In other words, encryption alone is not sufficient to achieve the same result as "freedom of speech" at a social level.
It's tempting to think you can solve political problems with technology, but ultimately you have to fight those battles the old fashioned way.
Re:Usenet Tradecraft: Survival in an Extremely Adversarial E...
by loup-vaillant on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:45AM
(#12129374)
I'm not sure the chilling effect you speak of is that big: it's personal information that you must not disseminate. I think one can engage in political discussions without revealing anything else than their opinions, which aren't personally identifiable in most cases.
Edit: and then there's stylometry, which may prevent one to say anything… sigh.
Extrapolating from this to other reasons you might operate in an adversarial environment, for instance political dissidence, this conclusion has a rather chilling effect. The content of the communication itself must be severely limited in how it can assist coordination of outside efforts in order to maintain the anonymity of the members. Or in the inverse, if the member's have strong identities (via PGP WoT, et al) then the /only/ barrier protecting them from their adversary is the control of the keys themselves.
Not that this is any great revelation, per se. But it means that in the cases where you're using encryption as the basis for communicating with a group in secret, that you still must experience a chilling effect on the content of your messages. In other words, encryption alone is not sufficient to achieve the same result as "freedom of speech" at a social level.