Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by adrenalinelol on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:22PM
(#12126444)
It's a shame too because one of the inhibiting factors of AI as complex as DeepMind is the fact it isn't cost effective due to its power consumption for quite a few tasks.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by bytefactory on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:26PM
(#12126454)
"In recent months, the Alphabet Inc. unit put a DeepMind AI system in control of parts of its data centers to reduce power consumption by manipulating computer servers and related equipment like cooling systems. It uses a similar technique to DeepMind software that taught itself to play Atari video games, Hassabis said in an interview at a recent AI conference in New York."
This part really incensed me. That's like describing SpaceX's rocket "as being based on similar technology as Wernher von Braun's V2 rockets in World War 2". I exaggerate for effect, but you get the point.
Edit: formatting.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by arbre on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:50PM
(#12126538)
I disagree. If you read the atari paper you will get plenty of details and you can infer how it is applied to electricity consumption. They were using reinforcement learning. The algorithms would learn to get a better score by looking at the screen and sending actions accordingly. Here you could imagine the same algorithm with energy consumption as a score, a set of datacenter metrics as the screen (state) and change of metrics as actions.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by argonaut on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @03:48AM
(#12127454)
Errr... No. Just no. Deep reinforcement learning is not some pixie dust that magically works for any problem with a reward function that you throw it at. It's astounding how commenters on HN think this is all "easy".
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by dmos62 on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:15AM
(#12128373)
This quickly went to you say this, I say this. These are very interesting statements, it would be nice if they were supported by citations.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by argonaut on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:24AM
(#12129208)
The poster I was replying to is really the one who needs to prove that deep RL is super easy like they were claiming.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by arcanus on Thursday July 21, 2016 @01:57PM
(#12138693)
> Here you could imagine the same algorithm with energy consumption as a score, a set of datacenter metrics as the screen (state) and change of metrics as actions.
What you have described is easily instantiated with any numerical optimization technique of the last 40 years. The devil for any of these problems is in the details.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by novaleaf on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @05:07PM
(#12132521)
While that may be true, I would say that your power consumption example is not related to the power conservation claim in the article.
You are talking about the power required to execute the AI, where the article is discussing the application of the AI to make a system more efficient.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by nattaylor on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:43AM
(#12129360)
More details available at http://googlegreenblog.blogspot.com/2016/07/deepmind-ai-redu...
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by bytefactory on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @12:32PM
(#12130329)
Also at https://deepmind.com/blog
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by mappingbabeljc on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:50PM
(#12126541)
they plan to publish more details in a research paper, AFAIK.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by ComodoHacker on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @07:44AM
(#12128257)
Don't forget it's Bloomberg, not Ars or TechCrunch.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by LeoPanthera on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @11:41PM
(#12126713)
Ironically if you have an ad-block there is an interstitial annoyance-delay. Seems like my ad-blocker is doing its job.
Re:Google Cuts Its Giant Electricity Bill with DeepMind-Powe...
by Hamcha on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @02:31AM
(#12127244)
In my experience disabling JS entirely on Bloomberg saves a lot of time (and bandwidth, I'd assume).
I once run a test: Loading time (with cache disabled) went from a full 18 seconds to just 6. Also no random flashing due to the header resizing. (but you lose videos and thumbnails) worth for me
The claims made would've made for a very interesting tech-dive into a novel use of machine intelligence, but no details were provided.